While carriers have traditionally used phone launches to lure customers and gain market share, last year’s free phone deals were easily copied by rivals and resulted in no competitive advantage, analysts say.

In a market where subscriber defections have been low as people hold on to their phones for longer, carriers initially introduced deals with less generous discounts on the iPhone 8 and iPhone X (AAPL), in a move analysts said would help margins.

Both new and existing customers who enroll in the Sprint Flex leasing program will get a free 64GB iPhone 8 if they trade in newer iPhone and Samsung models, Sprint said on Monday.

AT&T’s (T) video customers could buy a new iPhone 8 or 8 Plus, add a line and receive a $699 credit for a second device beginning with pre-orders on Friday.

Sprint (S) had previously said last Wednesday that customers who trade in an iPhone 6 or select Android devices can save 50% off the monthly lease payment of the iPhone 8 or 8 Plus.

The iPhone 8 model starts at $699, while the iPhone X will start at $999, Apple announced last Tuesday.

Carriers have been restrained on promotions for the new iPhones, and instead are using their strengths to drive differentiation, said Barclays analysts in a note on Monday.

AT&T looks to recover subscriber growth through free HBO (TWX) and cheap DirecTV Now promotions, while Sprint is focused on keeping subscriber losses low, Barclays said.

Barclays analysts characterized the initial promotions—including AT&T’s buy one, get one free deal—as largely in line with expectations, but said the carriers could ramp up promotions heading into the holidays, according to a note to clients on Monday.

Verizon Communications (VZ), the No. 1 wireless carrier in the U.S., declined to comment on plans for additional promotions. T-Mobile U.S. (TMUS) did not respond to requests for comment.