It’s tempting to think of bias as a fairly straightforward, albeit embarrassing, blind spot that can be identified with some respectful feedback, smoothed over with careful training and controlled with proper institutional vigilance.
Unless you’re a juvenile court judge from Louisiana. Who went to Louisiana State University (LSU). And you’re a big fan of their football team. And then your team loses, unexpectedly.
Then, you may be alarmed to discover that you are more likely to hand down longer sentences the week after that bummer of a game than if your team won. In fact, the effect happens only if you were negatively surprised by the outcome. If you expected a loss, you were fine. And it seems, the sentence will be harsher still if the defendant is black.
In a newly-updated working paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research, two researchers, Ozkan Eren and Naci Mocan, from LSU, examined juvenile court records from 1996 through 2012, looking to examine the relationship between “emotional shocks”- like those experienced by football fans – and a judge’s ability to actually judge.
“We investigate whether emotional shocks, experienced by a highly-educated group of individuals, have any impact on these individuals’ professional behavior which, by law, should be free of personal feelings and biases,” says the report.
The paper, aptly named Emotional Judges and Unlucky Juveniles, is a fascinating and accessible read. Could decision fatigue, lack of food breaks, or defendant misbehavior in the courtroom be to blame? Nope, nope and nope. These things, and others, were studied and accounted for. It was LSU football, they say.
The researchers calculated that each upset loss of the LSU football team generated excess punishments of juvenile defenders in Louisiana by a total of more than 1,332 days, including time in custody and probation, with 159 extra days of jail time for juveniles convicted of a felony.
“Furthermore, although the average sentence lengths (conditional on case, defendant and judge attributes) do not differ by defendant race in the absence of a football effect, it appears that an upset LSU football game loss increases the disposition length (sentence severity) of black defendants more severely in comparison to white defendants. Thus, the burden of the emotional trauma generated by the upset loss seems to fall on black defendants.”
Ozken and Mocan point out that because the bias is triggered by an “emotional shock,” it is not deliberate. But the research obviously raises some important concerns about the Louisiana judicial system specifically, as well as how to better manage the emotional humans at the helm of any major system.
“I think there are implications in a narrow area such as judicial decision-making, as well as in a more general area of ‘understanding and explaining human behavior,’” says Mocan. His next area of focus is on the broader impact of culture and institutions on individual behavior.
In the meantime, go Tigers?
On Point
| Judge grants partial stop on the Dakota Access Pipeline |
| The stoppage is only for part of the $3.8 billion project, and specifically addresses the issue whether the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has jurisdiction on private (and sacred) land. A tribal spokesperson reports that six people have been attacked and bitten by police dogs, and 30 more pepper sprayed. Another ruling comes Friday. |
| ABC News |
| Ava DuVernay’s Queen Sugar debuts, the crowd goes wild |
| Queen Sugar, the epic family drama adapted from a novel of the same name, debuted on Oprah’s OWN cable network last night. It did not disappoint. It was lush, beautiful, emotional and true, and managed to both celebrate black American culture without making it a self-consciously black story. Akiba Solomon has one of many excellent reviews, follow #queensugar for more. |
| Colorlines |
| Project Include's Ellen Pao on her mission to make tech more inclusive |
| The former Reddit CEO discusses “The Pao Effect,” which arose after her high profile gender discrimination trial against Kleiner Perkins. “It’s more of a path of trying to do the right thing,” she says of her new mission of making tech inclusive. “The solutions weren’t matching the problem.” She’s also working on a memoir to set the record straight about what motivated her to sue, among other things. |
| CNET |
| Training against micro-aggressions on college campuses |
| Clark University’s new chief diversity officer is instituting new training that help identify and curb “micro-aggressions” – comments or snubs that might not mean any harm but that are targeted at certain groups. Here’s a tip: Don’t ask an Asian student you don’t know for help on your math homework or randomly ask a black student if he plays basketball. Now here’s a question: Will this help grow a more racially savvy workforce? |
| New York Times |
The Woke Leader
| A South African protest on the policing of black hair triggers a global conversation |
| Last month, teenage girls from the Pretoria School for Girls, in South Africa, organized a protest over a long-standing rule that banned cornrows, braids and dreadlocks. The protest spread across the country and triggered a global conversation about African identity, appearance and behavior. "Schools should not be used as a platform to discourage students from embracing their African identity,” tweeted South Africa’s minister of arts. |
| NPR |
| Understanding the white Americans who have been left behind |
| Berkeley sociologist Arlie Russell Hochschild moved to Louisiana’s staunchly conservative Bayou country (go Tigers!) to get to know the conservative, white and often poor people who lived there, to understand their deep contempt for government systems. Her new book Strangers in their Own Land is based on five years and hundreds of in-depth interviews. |
| Vox |
| Native American leaders are climate change heroes |
| Bill McKibben, a former New Yorker staff writer and founder of a grassroots climate change organization, makes the case that the Standing Rock protest is a sign of essential leadership from the Native American community. “The fight for environmental sanity—against pipelines and coal ports and other fossil-fuel infrastructure—has increasingly been led by Native Americans, many of whom are in that Dakota camp today.” |
| New Yorker |
Quote
|
|---|
