Universal Music and Deezer reveal an ‘artist-centric’ music-streaming model that most artists won’t like

At the start of the year, Universal Music CEO Lucian Grainge told his staff that he wanted to catalyze a new, “innovative, artist-centric model” for streaming. He got Tidal on board in February with a rather vague and aspirational joint statement, and now UMG has struck what it calls “the first comprehensive artist-centric music streaming model” alongside Deezer, the French streamer that’s a market leader in Latin America. And it’s a big shift away from the status quo, where every stream is worth the same.

Under the model, Deezer will pay more to artists that people actually like listening to, which is a tiny minority of those whose music goes onto the platform—97% of uploaders generate a mere 2% of total streams. Those who get at least 500 unique listeners generating a total of at least 1,000 streams per month will get a “double boost,” though it’s not entirely clear what that means in terms of royalty payouts. Streams of songs that “fans actively engage with” (as opposed to songs that are merely thrown up by Deezer’s algorithm) will also get a double boost.

Here’s Deezer CEO Jeronimo Folgueira: “This is the most ambitious change to the economic model since the creation of music streaming and a change that will support the creation of high-quality content in the years to come.” And UMG EVP Michael Nash: “The goal of the artist centric model is to mitigate dynamics that risk drowning music in a sea of noise and to ensure we are better supporting and rewarding artists at all stages of their careers whether they have 1,000 fans or 100,000 or 100 million.”

All stages? That majority of artists who are hobbyists or just starting out, with only a handful of fans, seems to be left behind by the announcement. But then again, their payouts—if they receive any at all—are so negligible that the shift won’t make much of a difference. At that stage, getting people to listen to you at all is the big goal, not making money.

Also, thoughts and prayers to those who publish literal noise on Deezer—their content is being cut off from royalty payouts and will ultimately be replaced by Deezer’s in-house “functional music.” Folgueira again: “There is no other industry where all content is valued the same, and it should be obvious to everyone that the sound of rain or a washing machine is not as valuable as a song from your favorite artist streamed in HiFi.”

Bearing in mind that UMG also just got Google to agree to a partnership on the development of “an A.I. framework to help us work toward our common goals,” the music industry has some cause to take heart—though details and results still need to be seen. Deezer’s Folgueira told The Verge that other labels are also signing up to the new model, and I’d be surprised if this is the last platform to reach such an agreement with UMG.

More news below.

Want to send thoughts or suggestions to Data Sheet? Drop a line here.

David Meyer

NEWSWORTHY

New U.K. Google class action. Consumer rights campaigners have launched a class action against Google for allegedly stifling competition in the search-engine market and thereby contributing to the cost-of-living crisis. The litigants are after around $9 billion in damages, the Guardian reports. They’re specifically targeting Google’s tactics in getting phone manufacturers to make Google’s search the default on their devices, which is something that has already earned the company a $5 billion fine in the EU. The U.S. Justice Department is also suing Google over the issue.

OpenAI developer conference. OpenAI will hold its first developer conference in San Francisco on Nov. 6, the company announced in a blog post. The company has had an API since 2020 and says over 2 million developers are now using its services.

X’s advertiser repellant. Owner Elon Musk and CEO Linda Yaccarino insist that X’s critics are to blame for a 60% decline in U.S. ad revenue, but former brand safety and ad quality chief AJ Brown pins it on the platform’s recent decision to only limit the visibility of policy-violating content. “Helping people wrap their minds around the concept that violating a policy would no longer result in the removal of whatever was violating the policy, was a difficult message to communicate to people,” Brown, who left X in June, told Reuters.

ON OUR FEED

"By July, there are more than 130 large language models in China…A war of a hundred models has begun."

—Tencent vice president Jiang Jie at the launch of Hunyuan, the Chinese tech giant’s enterprise A.I. model. Tencent claims Hunyuan outperforms OpenAI’s ChatGPT at tasks such as the generation of lengthy texts.

IN CASE YOU MISSED IT

Ford CEO says people who buy electric vehicles ‘just want really good sh*t’, by Rachel Ventresca

The CEO of the hottest new car brand in Europe reveals what it will take to bring Cupra to America, by Christiaan Hetzner

In unorthodox move, Elon Musk borrowed $1 billion from SpaceX during ongoing Twitter deal, by Christiaan Hetzner

Intuit cut hundreds of jobs and spent at least $20 billion in a massive bet on AI. Today the company is revealing its new virtual assistant, by Geoff Colvin

September has been a bad month for Bitcoin. This year could be among the worst, by Marco Quiroz-Gutierrez

I coined the term ‘digital divide’ 25 years ago. Biden is providing the funding to bridge it–but one rule could squander this opportunity, by Larry Irving

BEFORE YOU GO

German data retention. Germany may be the birthplace of data-protection law, but its governments have spent a decade and a half (with a couple of court-ordered pauses) forcing network operators to store everyone’s telecommunications data for investigatory purposes. However, following a 2022 ruling by the EU’s top court—and consequent decisions published today (auf Deutsch, natürlich) by the German supreme court—the current government is finally backing down.

“In Germany, data retention is entirely illegal and therefore inapplicable,” federal Justice Minister Marco Buschmann said in a statement posted by his ministry, alongside a promise to swiftly remove the obligation (which is no longer enforceable as of today's ruling) from German law. The U.S. doesn’t have a comparable law, but Edward Snowden revealed the existence of a secret NSA data-retention program called MARINA, which stored the online metadata of Americans as well as foreigners, a decade ago.