Happy Pride Month. Paige here, filling in for Amber.
Like clockwork, every June, companies bring out their rainbow knick-knacks and share public statements encouraging LGBTQ+ individuals to be out and proud. A new Indeed survey of 732 LGBTQ individuals shows that many employees aren’t.
Just 30.7% of LGBTQ employees are out to everyone at work, while 43.2% are out to only certain groups or individuals, according to the survey. For transgender employees, 62% report feeling pressure to manage their identity at work, and 38% feel pressure to hide their identity altogether.
These statistics are damning evidence that, in 2023, many LGBTQ people believe they can’t be their authentic selves at work. But broader societal trends offer an answer. This year has seen a mounting wave of anti-LGBTQ attacks and bigotry, including nearly 500 anti-LGBTQ bills and threats of violence and boycotts against several corporate Pride campaigns.
Employees who decline to disclose their LGBTQ identity at work cite fear of discrimination, harassment, and concerns about career development. Many already believe their identity was a factor in being passed over for a promotion, targeted for performance reviews, and receiving less pay than non-LGBTQ colleagues.
“This is a big takeaway for the HR community in particular,” says Scott Dobroski, a career trends expert at Indeed. “If employers do not create more open, diverse, and inclusive workplaces, they are going to miss out on talent.”
The job site’s survey suggests that HR isn’t doing enough to make LGBTQ employees feel safe at work. While 89% of respondents say their company has a nondiscrimination policy, 22% say their company does not enforce this policy. Another 26% say no formal process exists to report discrimination to HR. Worse still, over a third of respondents do not feel comfortable reporting discrimination to HR, and 40% believe that the offending employee would face no real consequences if reported.
The hundreds of anti-LGBTQ bills cropping up across the country could also impact companies’ ability to attract LGBTQ talent. Over three-quarters of respondents say they would hesitate to apply for a position in a state with anti-LGBTQ legislation or even at a company headquartered in a state with anti-LGBTQ legislation.
“This community is feeling very vulnerable right now. It is affecting where and how they work,” says Dobroski. LGBTQ employees expect policies, programs, and actions demonstrating a commitment to inclusion. “It’s not HR’s responsibility to change laws or to even advocate for laws to be changed. What is HR’s responsibility is to live up to a company’s mission and values,” Dobroski says.
The survey identifies several actions for employers. Moreover, hesitant LGBTQ candidates say these actions would persuade them to apply to positions and companies in anti-LGBTQ states.
– Benefits: 73% of hesitant respondents say that benefits for LGBTQ employees, including short-term medical leave and fertility or adoption assistance, would make them more likely to apply. Yet only 23% of all respondents say their company currently offers LGBT-specific benefits.
– Inclusive policies: 81% of respondents would be more likely to apply to companies with policies that support LGBTQ employees. Forty-three percent say they would be hesitant to apply for a job that lacks inclusive language in the job posting.
– Remote work: 78% say remote work would make them more likely to apply.
– Inclusive office spaces: 40% of respondents would hesitate to apply for a job that did not have an identity-inclusive office. For example, gender-neutral bathrooms or an identity-inclusive dress code.
– Employee resource groups (ERGs): 81% of respondents agree that having an LGBTQ ERG creates a more comfortable work environment.
Paige McGlauflin
paige.mcglauflin@fortune.com
@paidion
Reporter's Notebook
The most compelling data, quotes, and insights from the field.
A.I. will spell doom for office workers with middling performance, as "mediocrity will be automated.”
“The benefit to employers here is clear. If a less experienced employee aided by an A.I. tool can be as effective as a more expensive, more experienced employee, you can guess what's going to happen next.” —Insider
Around the Table
A round-up of the most important HR headlines, studies, podcasts, and long-reads.
- Aging workforces without sufficient young talent to replenish their ranks innovate less. Economist
- Good news for teenagers: This year's summer job market will be strong. New York Times
- The average salary ranges posted on job listings have increased from 17.5% to 25% in the last year. Bloomberg
- The “boycott” of Chick-fil-A started when one far-right activist realized the chain had a vice president of DEI. Here’s a full timeline. CNN
Watercooler
Everything you need to know from Fortune.
Replacing tech workers. A.I. led to 4,000 layoffs last month, almost entirely in the tech sector, according to research from consulting firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas. —Rachel Shin
Labor market strength. The U.S. added 339,000 jobs in May, the latest jobs report found. —AP
You gotta mean it. Grindr's CEO says many employers professing to support LGBTQ rights don’t openly defend the community when it's under attack. —Phil Wahba
Future of work. HP CEO Enrique Lores believes A.I. will change people’s career trajectories. “It’s going to be really shifting the world from doing things to interpreting things.” —Steve Mollman
This is the web version of CHRO Daily, a newsletter focusing on helping HR executives navigate the needs of the workplace. Today’s edition was curated by Paolo Confino. Sign up to get it delivered free to your inbox.
