HR leaders are being pressured to do mandatory RTO even though most of them think it doesn’t matter for productivity

Brit MorseBy Brit MorseLeadership Reporter
Brit MorseLeadership Reporter

Brit Morse is a former Leadership reporter at Fortune, covering workplace trends and the C-suite. She also writes CHRO Daily, Fortune’s flagship newsletter for HR professionals and corporate leaders.

Businesspeople walking through turnstile
Most HR leaders say they believe requiring workers back into an office isn’t necessary for productivity, but they’re being asked to enforce the RTO policies anyways.
Getty Images

Good morning!

HR leaders are typically the ones to manage return-to-office policies. But just because they’re enforcing them, doesn’t mean they believe that they’re best for workers.

56% of HR leaders say they’re being pressured by CEOs to mandate in-office work arrangements, according to a new report of 1,000 human resource leaders from people-focused software platform Leapsome. However, 70% believe that collaboration can be just as effective out of the office and 79% say allowing employees to choose their work environment is best for productivity.

“During COVID we all learned that remote works, and that it helps people, and in fact, employees ask for it,” says Luck Dookchitra, VP of people and culture at Leapsome. “So there is a unique tension that arises, especially if [an RTO] policy is driven solely by leadership.”

Ensuring that HR leaders are able to manage CEO expectations while keeping their people happy certainly isn’t an easy task. However, Dookchitra says it helps if HR leaders can get to the root of why executives are so keen on getting workers back into the office, and share that sentiment in a way employees can relate to. She says that explaining the “why” behind such a directive is just as important as explaining the “how.”

“Even if you’re against it personally, you need to find a reason why,” says Dookchitra. “I think why it feels so stressful for HR leaders because they’re not providing a reason, many of them are just putting out a directive, and hoping for the best, which often doesn’t go well.” 

Dookchitra advises that when CHROs approach CEOs about RTO policies, they must be prepared, especially if they’re taking the opposing side. That means having data and insights from their own organization to see how policy changes are affecting the company on a larger scale. 

“Most of the time you don’t have an option, you have to agree and commit,” says Dookchitra. “So it’s really important to put forward the data, insights from your own organization, on employee sentiment and candidate feedback; so at the end of the day you have what you need to make your point, whether or not it’s going to go your way.”

Brit Morse
brit.morse@fortune.com

Around the Table

A round-up of the most important HR headlines.

The Supreme Court blocked an order for the Trump administration to return to work thousands of federal employees who were let go, allowing some of them to remain on paid administrative leave. Associated Press

The government is taking an ax to consulting contracts, and here’s a look at where DOGE is targeting its efforts. Business Insider

Microsoft fired two employees who disrupted the company’s anniversary event to protest the Israeli government being a customer. Bloomberg

Watercooler

Everything you need to know from Fortune.

Making an early impact. If you want to be a self-made millionaire by your 30s, follow Warren Buffett’s advice and  surround yourself with the right people. —Preston Fore

Bad behavior. Employees say their colleagues are embracing blame-shifting, snitching, and setting others up to fail and workplace backstabbing runs rampant. —Orianna Rosa Royle

Crisis communication. When shares fall to drastic levels, CEOs should resist the urge to sugarcoat the seriousness of a volatile situation. —Lila Maclellan

This is the web version of Fortune CHRO, a newsletter focusing on helping HR executives navigate the needs of the workplace. Sign up to get it delivered free to your inbox.