What really happened with the giant railroad strike that wasn’t—and how Warren Buffett was involved
After all-night negotiations that kept Americans on the edge of their seats, railroad employees have decided to forgo a planned strike early Thursday morning after companies and unions finally reached an agreement over better pay, working conditions, and benefits.
But the agreement is only tentative—and temporary. The railroad labor dispute came to a head this week with railroad employees demanding more flexible work schedules, wage increases, and better health care benefits.
Discontent among railroad employees stretches back years, though, with employees angry over cost-cutting measures that have led to record profits for rail companies and shareholders, but that have also wiped out thousands of jobs. And it involves everyone from U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders to Warren Buffett, who through his holding company, Berkshire Hathaway, owns one of the major railroad companies involved in the labor dispute.
Here’s what you need to know about the great railroad strike that wasn’t.
Had it gone through, the railroad strike could have disrupted the transportation of 30% of U.S. goods, and cost the U.S. economy as much as $2 billion a day, according to the Association of American Railroads. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, a body representing U.S. business interests, warned earlier this week that it could be a “national economic disaster.”
While a strike has been averted for now, the reasons behind the discontent go back years.
Years of cutbacks on expenses have led to staff shortages in the rail industry, employees argued. Strict attendance policies have been at the heart of the labor dispute, with workers saying they have been penalized for taking days off for being sick, or when tending to family emergencies. Fewer employees are doing more work, railroad workers say, and have to be on call at all hours.
Employment in railroads has seen a steep drop-off in recent years. The industry lost 40,000 jobs between November 2018 and December 2020 out of around 180,000 employees in 2018, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, reflecting a decades-long trend that has seen employment drop by nearly 90% since the late 1940s.
Over the past several years, in addition to cutting back on staff, railroad companies including BNSF have resorted to other cost-cutting measures such as making trains longer, while also hiking prices during the pandemic.
The result, railroad workers say, is that fewer employees are doing more work, and have to be on call at all hours.
Buffett’s labor disputes
While cost-cutting measures have made life harder for employees, they have led to windfall profits for Buffett and other rail tycoons.
Both BNSF and Union Pacific—the two largest freight rail corporations in the U.S.—posted record earnings last year. Shareholders have benefited from the profits, with U.S. rail companies spending $196 billion in buybacks and dividends since 2010, according to the Surface Transportation Board, an independent federal regulatory agency.
A spokesperson from Buffett’s BNSF told Fortune that the company was “pleased” that an agreement with labor unions had been reached and that a strike had been avoided. A spokesperson from Union Pacific told Fortune that the company was preparing to approve “historic wage increases” for employees once the agreement is ratified by union members.
The new agreement, if it goes through, will see compounded wages increase by up to 24% over the next five years including retroactive payments, according to a shared statement by railroad trade unions BLET and SMART. The agreement also loosens the industry’s attendance requirements, allowing for more expansive sick leave and medical exemption policies. The agreement still needs to be ratified by union members to be considered final.
Warren Buffett and BNSF have been at the center of railroad workers’ demands since last April, when railroad union members protested outside the first in-person annual meeting of Berkshire Hathaway shareholders in over two years in Buffett’s hometown of Omaha, demanding pay increases and better working conditions.
Earlier this week, Dennis Pierce, a top negotiator representing railroad unions, accused BNSF and Union Pacific of holding up progress, specifically where attendance and sick leave policies were concerned. BNSF responded to the accusations by calling Pierce’s claim “categorically false.”
Earlier this week, notable union ally Sen. Bernie Sanders urged Buffett to come to an agreement with protesters.
It isn’t the first time Sanders has argued with Buffett over his relationship with labor unions. Last year, Sanders sent a letter to Buffett asking him to intervene in a labor dispute between workers and a steelmaking company owned by Berkshire Hathaway. Buffett eventually declined to involve himself in the negotiations.
“During the pandemic, Mr. Buffett became $36 billion richer. He must ensure that rail workers receive decent wages and safe working conditions,” Sanders wrote in a Tuesday tweet.
Sign up for the Fortune Features email list so you don’t miss our biggest features, exclusive interviews, and investigations.