Meet the one-branch bank that did more PPP lending than Citi
This is the web version of The Ledger, Fortune’s weekly newsletter covering financial technology and cryptocurrency. Sign up here to get it free in your inbox.
When the data for Paycheck Protection Program, or PPP, lending finally came out last week, there was plenty to gawk at: there were public companies, pro sports teams, the Ayn Rand Institute—and a slew of errors.
What caught my eye, however, was the list of the top 15 PPP lenders. There are, of course, the usual suspects—JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America, which each oversee trillions of dollars in assets, are at the top of the list, having made more than $25 billion in PPP loans apiece. But No. 12, punching far above its weight and coming in ahead of Wall Street mainstays like Citizens Bank and BMO Harris, was a little-known New Jersey institution called Cross River Bank.
You may not have heard of Cross River. Until recently, it was known for being the bona fide bank behind financial technology companies that themselves are not technically banks, including cryptocurrency company Coinbase, payment processer Stripe, and consumer financing lender Affirm.
But Cross River, a community bank with only $2.5 billion in assets, made nearly $5.6 billion in PPP loans. That’s up from just $50 million in Small Business Administration-backed loans Cross River did in all of 2019.
To put this into context, Citi, which has more than $2.2 trillion in assets (or nearly 900 times as much money as Cross River), didn’t even make the top 15 lenders. So far, Citi has made about $3.4 billion in PPP loans, the bank disclosed when it reported earnings Tuesday. (A Citi spokesperson says the figure “reflects our smaller size as an SBA lender,” coming in 151st among all Small Business Administration lenders in 2019.)
What’s more, Cross River did all that lending despite giving out smaller loans: Its average loan size was just over $38,000, far less than any of the other banks among the top lenders, most of which averaged loans between $100,000 and $200,000 per business. That means Cross River loaned to more businesses than any other lender but Wells Fargo, Bank of America and JPMorgan—all three of which dwarf Cross River by other metrics. It also means, whereas the big banks prioritized lending to their existing customers which tend to be larger companies, Cross River’s loans went to the mom-and-pop shops and other true small businesses for which the PPP was intended: More than 95% of its borrowers were businesses with 20 employees or fewer.
So how did Cross River, which has only one physical branch, scale up its small business lending so dramatically in such a short time? As it turns out, partnering with fintechs to originate loans may be a more efficient way to serve lots of small businesses than just offering those loans directly under your own banner, particularly in a pandemic. After building a platform to automate PPP loan applications in less than 10 days, Cross River could then partner with more fintechs—now more than 30 in total—to funnel in their customers who wanted the stimulus funds, from non-bank lending companies like BlueVine and Kabbage to payroll software company Gusto.
“PPP demonstrated that fintech is the great equalizer,” Phil Goldfeder, Cross River’s senior vice president of public affairs, and a former elected official in New York, tells Fortune.
With a largely automated application portal, it didn’t matter whether the businesses were existing customers or how large or small they were; Cross River opened its virtual doors to any prospective PPP borrower—and it’s still accepting loan applications today, as the PPP deadline has been extended.
Cross River’s example may be a bellwether of what the future of finance and lending looks like. Rather than relying on regional branch networks and a bank’s own size, digital players can acquire customers nationally through slick technology and partnerships. (See also Rocket Mortgage, another digitally-focused offering whose parent company just filed for an IPO.)
And even though it seems that the rise of online banking has made brick-and-mortar branches less important, don’t underestimate traditional banks’ ongoing reliance on them. Even the Citi spokesperson, explaining why its PPP lending was relatively minor, told Fortune it was “because we have fewer than 700 branches nationwide and small businesses are typically served through branches.”
The Cross River and fintech model throws that out the virtual window. “It’s a totally different model in terms of how financial services scale,” says John Pitts, head of policy for Plaid, which connects banks including Cross River and others with many major fintech companies to power the data exchange between them. “Some of those community banks are going to be able to really expand their market size and market power, because they’re not going to be tethered to geography.”
A Swedish bank that doesn't pay bonuses is doing just fine ... Tokens built on Ethereum are now worth more than ETH itself ... Binance debuts crypto debit card in Europe and UK ... SoFi files for national banking charter ... Santander appoints three technologists to head digital transformation ... Bulgaria and Croatia take a big step towards adopting the Euro ... Low-cap cryptocurrency index hits all time high ... Vladimir Putin opponent Alexei Navalny uses bitcoin to raise funds.
Top U.S. banks face their worst quarter since the financial crisis ... Britain, fearing income tax hit, pressures bankers to get back to work ... Coronavirus is doing more for digital payments in India than demonetization laws did ... London banks urged to pay reparations for their role in slavery ... The Hong Kong dollar is looking shaky ... but U.S. threats to undermine it are 'self-defeating' ... At least 12 members of Congress benefited from PPP loans ... Canadian government paid half-brother of PM Justin Trudeau to give blockchain talk ... Instagram-famous phishing scammers caught by U.S. ... Circle freezes stablecoin accounts at law enforcement request.
The amount of money per week (give or take) that could disappear from the American economy when the expanded unemployment benefits implemented under the CARES act disappear on July 25 (no, not July 31). Unemployment nationwide was 17.8 million at the end of June, with each UI beneficiary receiving an additional $600 in weekly benefits. Economists have warned that without the additional aid, the U.S. economy is likely to slip back into recession.
FOMO NO MO'
“It wasn’t called the small business protection program or the microbusiness protection program. Companies in the 100- to 500-employee range have more payroll dollars than companies in the under-100-employees range. That’s just math.”
Michael Minnis, a professor at the Chicago Booth School of Business, on a key misperception of the coronavirus-relief Paycheck Protection loan program. As highlighted by Vox's Recode, the program was meant to protect worker wages, not small businesses themselves (it's right there in the name), but it has often been seen by the public as a small-business bailout. That misperception has fueled outrage over larger corporations receiving the loans, while the reality of the PPP has left many of the smallest businesses–those without much payroll to protect–out in the cold. Among other issues, Recode reports that the program's reliance on banks as middlemen has presented a major barrier for minority-owned businesses without existing banking relationships.
THE LEDGER'S LATEST
Five questions about Coinbase's rumored IPO - Jeff John Roberts
Trump admin quietly rolls back rules against predatory payday loans - Nicole Goodkind
Dozens of public companies kept millions in PPP loans - Jen Wieczner
TikTok traders engineer a Dogecoin pump - Robert Hackett
What is Dogecoin? - Robert Hackett
Revolut adds U.S. crypto brokerage services through Paxful - Jeff John Roberts
What causes crazy prices on Wayfair and Amazon - David Z. Morris
Goldman-backed startup Bond raises $32 million to let any company offer banking - Jeff John Roberts
Coinbase hires prominent former judge as its top lawyer - Jeff John Roberts
Will Tesla be added to the S&P 500? - Jen Wieczner
Big bank earnings: The good, the bad, and the ugly - Anne Sraders
Move over NASDAQ, the Shanghai Composite is on a bull run for the ages - Bernhard Warner
Europe tries to save its economy with elaborate giveaways - Katherine Dunn
Uncle Sam wants you! To report stimulus fraud - Anne Sraders
156 economists call for Congress to pass 'automatic' stimulus - Lance Lambert
Five theories on why the stock market is up 42% since March - Anne Sraders
Everything we've learned about how Joe Biden would run the economy - Nicole Goodkind
MEMES AND MUMBLES
This edition of The Ledger was curated by David Z. Morris. Contact him at email@example.com.