AIG’s CEO Says Maybe It’s Not “Too Big to Fail” Either

(FILES): This September 17, 2008 file photo shows the logo of American International Group Inc. outside their office in the lower Manhattan area of New York. The US Federal Bureau of Investigation is probing allegations of fraud by 26 Wall Street firms including several investment giants whose collapse sent world markets into turmoil, US media said September 23, 2008. The FBI has set its sights on investment titan Lehman Brothers, mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and insurer AIG, in a wide-reaching inquiry that comes as lawmakers rush to agree a 700-billion-dollar government bailout of the troubled US financial sector.    AFP PHOTO / Files / Stan HONDA (Photo credit should read STAN HONDA/AFP/Getty Images)
(FILES): This September 17, 2008 file photo shows the logo of American International Group Inc. outside their office in the lower Manhattan area of New York. The US Federal Bureau of Investigation is probing allegations of fraud by 26 Wall Street firms including several investment giants whose collapse sent world markets into turmoil, US media said September 23, 2008. The FBI has set its sights on investment titan Lehman Brothers, mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and insurer AIG, in a wide-reaching inquiry that comes as lawmakers rush to agree a 700-billion-dollar government bailout of the troubled US financial sector. AFP PHOTO / Files / Stan HONDA (Photo credit should read STAN HONDA/AFP/Getty Images)
Photo by Stan Honda — AFP/Getty Images

A judge’s ruling that MetLife (MET) is not “too big to fail” opens up an opportunity for insurer American International Group to seek an exemption from the tag, AIG Chief Executive Peter Hancock said on CNBC on Thursday.

However, Hancock said AIG (AIG) was “reserving judgment” for now.

AIG’s near collapse in 2008 and its $182 billion bailout by the U.S. government was the driving force behind the inclusion of certain non-bank financial companies, including AIG, as “systemically important financial institutions,” or SIFI.

The SIFI designation means regulators believe a collapse of the company could devastate the U.S. financial system just as much as the failure of a major bank and comes with increased regulatory oversight and capital requirements.

Hancock, who said “the whole world was somewhat surprised” by the MetLife ruling, noted that AIG had shrunk its balance sheet, giving it a strong case to get its SIFI tag removed.

AIG’s mortgage insurance unit, United Guaranty, filed for an initial public offering on Wednesday as part of AIG’s plan to become smaller. The company also plans to sell its broker-dealer network.

Activist investor Carl Icahn, who is AIG’s fifth largest shareholder, has been pushing the insurer to become smaller and simpler to allow it to shed its label as a non-bank SIFI.

General Electric’s GE Capital, another non-bank, formally asked the U.S. government on Thursday to stop designating it a SIFI.

Shares of AIG, which have fallen 12% so far this year, were little changed at $54.55 in premarket trading.