Marissa Mayer’s three-year effort to turn around Yahoo has been a major-league leadership saga, as it was destined to be. Events of the past few days suggest – but don’t yet dictate – that the saga is in its final chapters.
Yahoo was a mess when Mayer left Google to take over as CEO in July 2012. At that time no major troubled Internet company had ever been turned around, and this looked like as good a test as any of whether it was even possible. Mayer had been a star executive at Google and was widely hailed as a brilliant hire.
In a sense she has done what she was hired to do, changing strategic direction and making bold investments. But the numbers tell the unhappy story of how her moves have worked out so far. Yahoo’s market cap is $31 billion. Its stake in Alibaba (acquired long before Mayer arrived) is worth $30 billion, and its stake in Yahoo Japan (ditto) is worth $8.1 billion. Apply some tax-related discounts to those values to reflect what the company could actually net by selling, and add $7.6 billion of cash and other current assets Yahoo held as of September 30, and we see that investors figure Yahoo’s actual businesses are worth approximately nothing.
That situation is not, as they say, sustainable. Fortune’s Erin Griffith explains how activist investor Jeffrey Smith’s Starboard Value Fund bought a big stake in Yahoo last year and reasonably urged Mayer to off-load its Alibaba and Yahoo Japan holdings so investors could buy or sell them separately from Yahoo. Mayer developed a plan to do so but ran into a problem: The IRS would not assure Yahoo that spinning off those investments in the way planned would be tax-free. Yahoo’s board decided the risk was worth taking and announced it would go ahead. Now Smith has concluded the plan is too risky and is pressing Mayer and the board to do the opposite, sort of – sell Yahoo’s core operating businesses wholly or in pieces for whatever they might fetch, leaving Yahoo as merely a vessel for owning shares of Alibaba and Yahoo Japan.
Smith argues that without such drastic action, Yahoo is in an irretrievable vortex of doom because it can’t attract top-level talent with stock incentives, since the stock’s performance merely reflects the performance of Alibaba and Yahoo Japan. Without the best talent, the company can never build its business to a point where it outweighs the performance of the Asian assets, leaving the company forever trapped.
Of course Mayer disagrees vehemently with that reasoning, telling Wall Street analysts recently that the company is well positioned “to deliver long-term sustainable growth for our investors.” But investors have zero reason to believe her assurances, which is why envisioning any kind of long-term future for Yahoo is growing increasingly hard.
Maybe no one could have saved Yahoo. Or maybe Mayer still can and will. But how about this for a leadership challenge: One way or another it seems likely that Yahoo’s businesses will soon be standing on their own, trying to persuade the world that they’re worth anything at all.
You can share Power Sheet with friends and followers here.
What We’re Reading Today
UnitedHealth threatens to pull out of Obamacare
CEO Stephen Hemsley says enrollment is too low and usage too high, causing millions of dollars of annual losses. He says Obamacare lets enrollees leave plans too easily. If he ends UnitedHealth’s participation, millions of people would lose lower priced insurance options and President Barack Obama‘s signature health law would suffer another blow. USA Today
Regulator says VW may buy back vehicles
California Air Resources Board chief Mary Nichols said in an interview that Volkswagen will likely have to buy back a number of cars with emissions-test-cheating software. The company today tells U.S. regulators how it plans to address the issue; having to buy back all 482,000 affected U.S. vehicles would dramatically increase the scandal’s already massive cost. CEO Matthias Müller announced that VW would spend $1 billion less on research and development next year and would delay factory openings in order to help fund VW’s response. Fortune
House passes strict refugee screening bill
The House overwhelmingly approved a bill that would require the F.B.I. director, the Department of Homeland Security secretary, and the national intelligence director to certify that every Syrian and Iraqi refugee entering the U.S. poses no threat. Led by House Speaker Paul Ryan, the move is a rejection of President Obama‘s plea to admit refugees on humanitarian grounds. It’s unclear if the bill will pass the Senate. NYT
A good first day
Shares of payment processor Square, offered at a surprisingly low IPO price of $9 yesterday, jumped 45%, closing at $13.07. Jack Dorsey‘s company gave hope to tech unicorns with high private-market valuations that are contemplating IPOs. Match Group, owner of Tinder and other dating sites, also listed yesterday and rose 23%. Entrepreneur
Building a Better Leader
U.S. companies hinting at wage pressure problems
Nearly 20 S&P 500 companies stated that wage pressure and labor costs are becoming headwinds. Reuters
Watch out for microaggressions
Subtle, everyday actions can result in sexual discrimination and racial bias that forces out some of your best talent. Fortune
Building emotional intelligence is a skill
It’s one you can learn, and it’ll help you deal with office drama. Without it, you might just pop. The Atlantic
AstraZeneca, Sanofi agree to share
The two European drug companies don’t plan to merge but will share 210,000 chemical compounds in order to encourage innovation. No money changes hands in the deal. It’s a unique tactic by AstraZeneca CEO Pascal Soriot and Sanofi’s Olivier Brandicourt meant to protect the companies from the large competitors resulting from U.S. pharma mergers. Fortune
South Korea and North Korea will hold talks
Officials of the two countries will speak next week. The talks followed North Korean leader Kim Jong Un‘s outreach and could lead to higher level discussions of peace between the two countries, which were fighting as recently as August. CNN
China cracks an underground bank
The bank conducted over $64 billion of illegal foreign exchange transactions, says the government; more than 370 people were arrested. President Xi Jinping has been cracking down on corruption, particularly in the financial sector, after the Chinese stock market troubles this summer. Bloomberg
Up or Out
Google has hired board member Diane Greene to run its enterprise cloud business. NYT
Nasdaq is set to name Adena Friedman CEO, succeeding Bob Greifeld, who’s preparing for retirement. Fortune
Fortune Reads and Videos
Congress isn’t ready to tackle inversions
Lawmakers can’t decide the best way to stop U.S. companies from moving overseas for tax purposes. Fortune
Facebook testing ex-focused app
The tool would let users select what type of posts they want to see from an ex after a relationship status change. Fortune
More Hispanics are leaving the U.S. than entering
It has been going on for a decade as Mexican adults view life in the U.S. differently. Fortune
The FDA approves genetically modified salmon
But it’s unclear how many supermarkets will sell food from the first ever approved GMO animal. Fortune
Vice President Joseph Biden turns 73 today. Biography
Share Today’s Power Sheet:
|Produced by Ryan Derousseau|