Yesterday’s mass call for a six-month moratorium on the development of next-generation A.I. models, for safety purposes, has not elicited much response from the companies at the center of the fray, such as OpenAI, Microsoft and Google. But the letter—signed by everyone from Elon Musk to philosopher and historian Yuval Noah Harari—has certainly sparked a great deal of commentary, much of it critical.
The thing is, those criticizing the call for a pause on A.I. development have quite different reasons for doing so. Here’s a rough guide to the various arguments we’re seeing.
1) The signatories over-hype A.I. and generally have the wrong motivations. Computational linguistics expert Emily Bender mocks the letter for claiming that “contemporary A.I. systems are now becoming human-competitive at general tasks.” While she agrees with some of what the letter calls for, she accuses its authors of “unhinged A.I. hype, helping those building this stuff sell it,” and argues that policymakers should rather focus on how technology is being used to “concentrate and wield power.” A similar critique is made by the German tech critic Jürgen Geuter (alias “tante”), who dismisses the letter as “wishful worries of a group of people who read way too much science fiction and way too little about the political economy and structures of reality.” Both Bender and Geuter suggest the call is suspicious because it was published by the Future of Life Institute, which espouses a controversial ethical stance called longtermism that focuses on humanity’s very-long-term survival.
2) The pause would do nothing to mitigate existing A.I. threats. Princeton computer scientists Sayash Kapoor and Arvind Narayanan similarly argue that the letter focuses on speculative threats while proposing nothing to mitigate the harms that can arise from today’s A.I. technology: the spread of misinformation through careless use, the unpaid exploitation of existing artworks and writings, and security risks such as the leaking of personal data and the propagation of worms.
3) Business is business. Tim Hwang, the CEO of regulatory-data outfit FiscalNote—which is now letting OpenAI’s ChatGPT draw on some of its repository—yesterday told me he thought the letter’s authors had valid concerns, but: “It’s hard to put the genie back in the bottle at this point. You’ve got an arms race of tens of billions of dollars between the world’s largest technology companies. There’s too much at stake at this point in multiple different geographies to be able to roll back time here. It’s also somewhat impractical, I think, to tell an entire industry to stop making money.”
4) Why hand an advantage to China? “Let’s pretend magically that OpenAI, Amazon, Microsoft, and Google stop, do you really think the Chinese are going to stop? Or the Russians? There’s no way,” veteran tech investor Daniel Petre told the Australian Financial Review. The Center for Data Innovation, a reliably pro-Big Tech think tank, also raised the specter of China racing ahead in its argument that the U.S. should accelerate rather than pause its A.I. development.
5) It could set a dangerous precedent. The influential computer scientist Andrew Ng called the moratorium call “a terrible idea” because government intervention would be the only possible way to enforce it. “Having governments pause emerging technologies they don’t understand is anti-competitive, sets a terrible precedent, and is awful innovation policy,” he tweeted. A sort-of counterpoint from Arati Prabhakar, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, at an Axios conference yesterday: “There’s a lot of conversation about, ‘let’s pull the plug,’ but I’m not sure there is a single plug.”
It doesn’t sound like a moratorium is coming soon—however, the Federal Trade Commission just received an official complaint asking it to freeze ChatGPT’s development, and a similar call also just went out to European regulators, so let’s see. More news below.
Want to send thoughts or suggestions to Data Sheet? Drop a line here.
David Meyer
Data Sheet’s daily news section was written and curated by Andrea Guzman.
NEWSWORTHY
Microsoft weighs ads in Bing Chat. Microsoft is experimenting with incorporating advertising in Bing Chat, its internet search chatbot powered by GPT-4. The chatbot has occasionally served up clearly labeled ads in its responses to some users since its launch, TechCrunch reports. The features Microsoft is considering include displaying more links from a publisher when a user is hovering over a link and sharing ad revenue with partners whose content contributed to the chat, according to a Microsoft blog post.
Cuts at Roku. U.S. streaming device maker Roku is laying off 6% of its workforce, or 200 employees. The company said the move is part of its efforts to lower its year-over-year operating expense growth and prioritize projects that it believes will have a higher return on investment. Roku will also be subleasing offices that aren’t currently occupied. This is the second round of layoffs for Roku, which shed 200 employees in November.
Midjourney stops free trials. The San Francisco Bay Area–based A.I. startup has halted free trials of its service after A.I.-generated images of Donald Trump being arrested and the pope in a Balenciaga jacket went viral and were mistaken for real photos, the Washington Post reports. Midjourney CEO and founder David Holz announced the change Tuesday, saying there’s been “extraordinary demand and trial abuse.” Operating with a full-time staff of 11 employees, the company released its newest and most advanced software version earlier this month. Known as version 5, the software can depict images of people with high quality.
SIGNIFICANT FIGURES
30%
—The share of adolescent girls in a recent survey who experience “availability stress” using Snapchat. The percentage of girls who feel pressure to be responsive on Instagram and TikTok is more than six percentage points lower.
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT
A group of college students are sending a rover the size of a shoebox to the moon, by Prarthana Prakash
Disney joins Microsoft and Snapchat as latest big-name company to slink away from metaverse ambitions, by Marco Quiroz-Gutierrez
Mark Zuckerberg brings a DJ to one of Meta’s onsite cafes to lure workers to return to the office, by Chris Morris
Disney joins Microsoft and Snapchat as latest big-name company to slink away from metaverse ambitions, by Marco Quiroz-Gutierrez
More companies are watching their remote workers WFH on camera—but it’s costing them big time, by Jane Thier
BEFORE YOU GO
Arc’s mobile browser is now available. The Browser Company has released a companion app for its Arc browser for iPhones. Arc needs to be set up on a Mac before the iPhone app can be used and isn’t available on Windows yet, The Verge reports. To get access to the Mac version, you can join a waitlist or get an invite from an Arc user. “It's NOT a replacement for your default mobile browser (yet). But it teases our dreams for the future of computing,” CEO Josh Miller tweeted.
This is the web version of Data Sheet, a daily newsletter on the business of tech. Sign up to get it delivered free to your inbox.