PayPal may be pinning some of its hopes of future growth on Pinterest.
Reports surfaced Wednesday that PayPal, the payments titan that owns Venmo, is in talks to acquire Pinterest, known for its digital mood boards composed of images (or “pins”), for a potential price of roughly $45 billion, Bloomberg first reported and outlets including CNBC and the New York Times confirmed. PayPal did not respond to Fortune’s request for comment, and Pinterest declined to comment to Fortune.
A possible Pinterest acquisition could make sense from a couple of angles, especially as social commerce—or buying products on social media—takes off (think recent shopping integrations on popular apps like Instagram and TikTok).
And some analysts, at least, are bullish on the prospect. “I think this is a smart acquisition” if it occurs, Wedbush analyst Moshe Katri tells Fortune. “I think the market is still struggling to understand the logic, [but] I believe the market will get there just because strategically, this could be a game changer” if PayPal “executes it well,” he argues. “It’s all about user monetization.”
The potential deal would be “a significant positive” for PayPal, Katri wrote in a note on Wednesday following the reports, as buying Pinterest could be a boon for PayPal’s “ongoing monetization initiatives on both sides” of its merchant and consumer platforms, particularly if Pinterest’s “social commerce platform gets integrated with Honey’s A.I. into PayPal’s destination app.” (PayPal acquired Honey, a coupon browser add-on and app, in 2019.) He suggests there’s “opportunity for engagement to accelerate within the destination app post-integration.”
Indeed, Colin Sebastian, a research analyst at Baird, agrees “there would be clear synergies in combining PayPal’s ‘bottom of the funnel’ digital wallet and deals (Honey) platform with Pinterest’s search, discovery, and inspiration (top of funnel) platform,” fueling PayPal’s touted “super-app” ambitions, he wrote in a note Wednesday. He points out that with Pinterest’s over 450 million monthly users looking for products and things they want to buy, that “massive source of value (and data)” could be a boon for PayPal’s services and “remove friction” when purchasing things.
Digital marketing, meanwhile, is an “underappreciated part of PayPal’s plans,” Sebastian argues. A Pinterest–PayPal deal could propel PayPal into “one of the leading digital marketing platforms, combining Pinterest’s existing ad business with PayPal’s valuable transactional data,” he wrote.
Price tag–wise, Pinterest’s stock is off roughly 30% from its all-time high in February as the platform has been losing users—a discount from when reports swirled that Microsoft was looking into buying the firm at around $51 billion early this year. Reports suggest PayPal is considering paying around $70 per share for the company (roughly $45 billion, per Bloomberg), but those like Baird’s Sebastian, at least, suggest PayPal might need to cough up something above that $70 threshold. “With Pinterest shares under significant pressure since [second quarter] results due to user churn, we do not believe the valuation embeds the significant opportunity of the platform to expand monetization in both the core U.S. and international markets,” he wrote.
A social strategy
To be sure, this certainly wouldn’t be Pinterest’s first foray into social commerce: It already has a partnership with Shopify. But for Pinterest, a PayPal team-up “makes strategic sense,” Katri wrote, as a deal “at its heart is based on the growing and critical theme of social commerce, and integrating a payments business with a shoppable social app is forward-looking in our view,” he argues (though Katri tells Fortune it’s not necessarily new to PayPal, as he argues the Venmo app is “also a social commerce tool”). It’s estimated social commerce could grow from $26.8 billion last year to $52.5 billion in 2023, he points out.
Though Pinterest’s user engagement is below that of “typical social platforms,” Katri notes, “the intent of users is quite different. It’s proving to be an important channel for digital advertisers that can tie together top of funnel intentions increasingly with transactions at the bottom of the funnel,” he wrote. “Pinterest has been intently focused on driving greater shoppability into its platform,” and he notes that product inventory grew almost 50% in the second quarter “driven by Pinterest’s Shopify partnership expansion.”
It seems for now that at first glance, Pinterest investors are a bit more enthused at the prospect than PayPal’s: Pinterest stock rose nearly 13% on Wednesday, while PayPal’s slumped roughly 5% by the close.
But until any deal is confirmed, it looks like we’ll just have to put a pin in it.
More finance coverage from Fortune:
- 4 things to know about stimulus checks in 2022 and beyond
- GameStop report from SEC sheds new light on meme stock mania—conspiracies and all
- How high Goldman Sachs predicts home prices will go in 2022
- Mortgage rates may spike 30% next year, according to a new forecast
- These markets are expected to be the hottest for real estate in 2022
Subscribe to Fortune Daily to get essential business stories delivered straight to your inbox each morning.