As Europe’s fashion giants brace for what could be the toughest leg of their expansion in China, a South African retail tycoon has launched a bold assault on the world’s most populous nation.
Christo Wiese is promising to open 500 of his New Look stores in just three years, catapulting the British brand into the same league in China as the world’s top fashion chains – Spain’s Inditex and Sweden’s H&M.
His plan is to make most of the clothes in China to ensure they cater to local tastes and can get to stores quickly – a strategy similar to the one successfully pursued in Europe by Zara-owner Inditex.
The arrival of New Look – and its local sourcing strategy – poses a new risk for the likes of H&M and Inditex, already suffering from slower growth in China, fierce competition for real estate and the cost of investing in ecommerce.
H&M is opening more stores in China this year than anywhere else in the world and the country is already the second biggest market for Inditex outside Spain.
China is a big draw for retailers who hope to tap the aspirations of a fast-growing middle class, with mid-range names benefiting as consumers trade down from luxury brands since Beijing’s clampdown on corruption and conspicuous spending.
But recent history offers plenty of examples of failure. Western brands that have struggled in China include Gap Inc , Abercrombie & Fitch and Marks and Spencer , which decided last year to close five stores in smaller cities to focus on flagship stores in large cities and online.
“Most of the Western fashion labels that are mid-range fail in China. A large part of it is that the styles and the fit are so completely different,” said Shaun Rein, founder of market intelligence firm China Market Research.
LOCAL TASTES, LOCAL SOURCING
New Look, a chain founded in 1969 and bought last year by Wiese’s investment vehicle Brait SE, does not want to make the same mistake. It now runs 94 stores in China, out of a global total of 852, and hopes to have up to 150 by next March.
“I will definitely give it a try if it is a foreign brand and as long as I like it,” said Chen Jie, a 32-year-old businessman from Shenzhen who was carrying an H&M bag in a shopping district in Hong Kong. “Price is not an issue but the design and quality must be good.”
While New Look is cashing in on the popularity in China of British style – it is adding the “London” tag to its logo for its Chinese stores and website – it is also catering for local tastes.
Sven Gaede, managing director of New Look’s international business, says the firm has an advantage over many European rivals as 85% of what it sells in China is sourced locally and more than a third is designed exclusively for China.
That has allowed New Look to tap into the current popularity in Asia of culottes – flared, three-quarter length trousers. Gaede said they account for 12% of the firm’s sales in China, though they are not popular in its European markets.
“South Korea and Japan drive a lot of the trends that the Chinese customer seeks, so our ability to be able to identify those trends, source them locally and get them into our stores quickly is key,” said Gaede.
That helps explain the success of the Uniqlo chain of Japan’s Fast Retailing in China, which already has almost 500 stores in the country and is aiming for 1,000 stores in about five years – more than in Japan.
“It’s pretty hard for the foreign fast brands to do the localisation that Uniqlo does in China as it was born with the Asian gene,” said Violet Shen, a marketing executive in Shanghai.
The “fast fashion” model was pioneered by Inditex, which can bring new styles from the catwalk to stores in Europe within days from factories mostly in Spain and North Africa. However, Inditex does not have the same advantage in China.
Inditex plans to add 60 stores in the next few years to the 582 it already runs in China, but it serves them from its logistics centres in Spain.
“As their proportion of sales increases in the East, it challenges this model. You can’t hub out of Spain,” said Dominic Jephcott, chief executive of supply chain experts Vendigital.
For more on retail news, watch Fortune’s video:
New Look is not the first Western retailer to try to bring the Inditex model to China.
Denmark’s Bestseller, which runs brands like Vero Moda and Jack & Jones, says over 90% of its products sold in China are also produced in China and most of the designs for the Chinese market are adjusted to local tastes.
That has helped the family-owned firm to become the clear leader in China, with more than 6,800 stores in over 300 cities, to give it a 2% share of the fragmented market, according to market research firm Euromonitor.
Anders Kristiansen ran the China business of Bestseller before taking over as New Look chief executive in 2013. Gaede said Kristiansen’s experience in Asia is one of the reasons behind the group’s aggressive expansion strategy.
H&M also buys many of its garments in China – the country accounts for about a quarter of its global sourcing.
But the Swedish firm does not make a big point of adjusting its ranges for China, where it has opened 47 stores in the last nine months, taking its total to 400.
“We see that fashion becomes more and more global and that China doesn’t differ much from the rest of the world regarding trends and fashion,” said investor relations head Nils Vinge.
“There are of course local differences but that is true for every market. H&M has a business model that can adapt to this,” Vinge said, declining to elaborate.
Rein of China Market Research says Western brands must strike a delicate balance.
“You have to keep your global brand image and you can’t be that creatively different in China than other markets. The Chinese travel around the world,” he said. “It is good to localise. But it hard to localise an aspiration.”
STORES VS ECOMMERCE
A bigger challenge for New Look may be to secure the right locations, especially as rivals also seek to add hundreds of stores in the coming years.
“To find 500 stores of real estate and roll that out in the right way … I think it is virtually impossible,” said Franklin Yao, managing partner at strategy consultants Smith Street.
But the more established New Look’s brand becomes in China, Gaede said, the better the locations and terms it will be offered, adding that the firm was now pushing into smaller cities.
“We are less wedded to the number each year and we are more wedded to getting quality locations,” he said.
Meeting soaring Chinese demand for buying clothes online is also tough.
Most international brands initially launch on Chinese ecommerce sites like JD.com and Alibaba’s Tmall and Taobao, but are keen to build up their own online operations to protect margins and integrate ecommerce and store services.
New Look is currently available on Tmall and JD.com, but plans its own transactional site in the next 12 to 18 months.
Partnering with Chinese sites and local payment and delivery service providers is essential to reach consumers across such a vast country, said Vendigital’s Jephcott.
“It is a hard physical push and a very hard digital push, all premised on a strong relationship with the logistics partner like Taobao,” Jephcott said, noting that Taobao has established a delivery network of micro-stores even in small towns.
