Great ResignationDiversity and InclusionCompensationCEO DailyCFO DailyModern Board

Power Sheet – December 15, 2015

December 15, 2015, 3:24 PM UTC

The best leaders have the self-confidence to develop other excellent leaders and to acknowledge publicly, sometimes years in advance, that they will someday leave the scene. It’s remarkable how many CEOs, even those who are grandly successful and widely lauded, just cannot bring themselves to do those things. A notorious example was a long-ago boss of mine, CBS founder and CEO William S. Paley. He had five designated successors, two of whom, John Backe and Arthur Taylor, died recently, and none of whom ever succeeded him. Deeply insecure despite his huge achievements, he couldn’t bear to let go.

Today we see two excellent business leaders who are doing it right. One gets a lot of attention and one doesn’t, but they both deserve study as exemplars of how succession at the top is done.

Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf and the board last month named Tim Sloan president and COO, positioning him as the clear favorite to succeed Stumpf. That succession may not take place for three years; Stumpf is only 62. He’s telling the world who the next boss is likely to be, while a spokeswoman also noted that “the company’s succession plan does include other viable candidates.” That’s exactly what investors, customers, and employees like to hear. In 2018, when the day comes for Stumpf to step down, no one will bat an eye.

The less visible current example is what’s happening at Exxon Mobil. It’s odd to say that it’s less visible; Exxon is one of the world’s largest companies, far bigger than Wells, with a market cap of $317 billion. But Rex Tillerson, CEO since 2006, doesn’t get much attention and doesn’t want it. Last Friday – the day of the week when you announce things that you don’t intend to attract much notice – he and the board named Darren Woods president and made him a director. Like Stumpf, Tillerson isn’t going anyplace soon; he won’t turn 65 until 2017. He, too, wants the world to know that the company’s leadership is predictable and under control as far as the eye can see.

Seamless transitions don’t just happen. They reflect decades of leadership development, including the increasingly difficult task of holding onto high-potential leaders. Both Woods, 50, and Wells’s Sloan, 55, joined their current employers at about the age of 27. Before their latest promotions, each ran a major part of the business, Woods as chief of Exxon’s refining and chemicals operations, Sloan as head of wholesale banking at Wells. They’re well prepared to take over.

Naming a likely successor well in advance carries at least a couple of advantages that may not be immediately obvious. One is that luring those guys away has suddenly become a lot more difficult or expensive for a competitor to do. Another is that internal anxiety over the identity of the next boss quiets way down. Uncertainty over an organization’s future can drain productivity almost to zero, and while gossip and speculation are eternal, clear succession minimizes them.

The latest moves at Wells Fargo and Exxon illustrate CEO succession done right. Maybe you didn’t even notice them. That’s one sign of how skillful they were.

You can share Power Sheet with friends and followers here.

What We're Reading Today

Sumner Redstone's mental competence challenge continues

A former companion of the 92-year-old Viacom chairman has filed a petition arguing that a November document signed by Redstone was forged and that the court should order a medical examination. Manuela Herzer also argues that Viacom CEO Philippe Dauman does not have regular interactions with Redstone, as Dauman claimed in a court filing. Redstone's lawyers filed to reject the petition. The court battle over Redstone's mental competence has raised questions among Viacom investors. NYT

J.J. Abrams "terrified" about Star Wars

The director of Star Wars: The Force Awakens, which opens Friday, may be a victim of expectations. Investors may view anything less than a $1.5-billion to $2-billion global box office hit as a failure. Steven Spielberg, a friend of Abrams, says the  director is "terrified." Disney CEO Robert Iger has invested billions in the franchise. Fortune

Will Cruz and Trump face off tonight?

Texas Senator Ted Cruz will attract heavy attention at tonight's Republican debate, having rocketed in the polls as Ben Carson has faltered. He has apparently consolidated support of hardline conservatives and now must chip away at Donald Trump's lead. That requires walking a fine line; he doesn't want to push Trump supporters away but also can't appear weak.  Reuters

Bowe Bergdahl faces court martial

Commander of U.S. Army Forces Command Gen. Robert Abrams announced the charges against Sgt. Bergdahl, who faces a potential sentence of life in prison. Abrams's decision breaks from the recommendations of the officer overseeing Bergdahl's case, who suggested a special court martial with no potential jail time. Bergdahl disappeared from his unit in Afghanistan in 2009 and was held captive by the Taliban for five years. CNN

Building a Better Leader

Stress can help your team...

…if properly framed. That's how the Army uses the stress of war to build unity. Inc.

Startups haven't disrupted the gender pay gap

Women make 77 cents to every dollar their male counterparts make at startups, in line with the national average. Fortune

CFOs and workers split on perks

Only 14% of CFOs think employees want telecommuting, but 23% of workers say they want it. The gap on health and wellness benefits is even larger. Business Insider

Worth Considering

Gilt Groupe in talks with Hudson's Bay for $250M

If the deal closes, Gilt would sell at a fraction of what it was valued at, $1.1 billion, only a few years ago. The potential decision by co-founder Kevin Ryan to unload the online fashion retailer would bring in less than the company has raised in VC funding - about $280 million - since 2007. Gerald Storch, CEO of Hudson's Bay, parent of Saks Fifth Avenue, could pair the online retailer with his off-price brands.  WSJ

The way forward for Yahoo

Some investors are supporting SpringOwl Asset Management managing director Eric Jackson's proposal for Yahoo. Key elements: parting ways with CEO Marissa Mayer and focusing on Yahoo's strengths in sports and finance. Jackson argues that Mayer lacks the operational experience to pull off this type of turnaround and that  Yahoo shouldn't sell its core businesses now, as others have proposed, since it would be selling low. Fortune

New rules for drones

The Federal Aviation Administration announced that all drones must be registered in a national database. Some 700,000 new drones are expected to be purchased for the holidays. The decision by the FAA and Secretary of Transportation Anthony Foxx creates the first rules for recreational unmanned drones. Now the agency has to figure out how to enforce the rules. NYT

Up or Out

Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide CEO Adam Aron has resigned to become AMC Entertainment Holdings CEO. CFO Thomas Mangas will replace Aron as Starwood works through its acquisition by Marriott International.  BusinessWire

Barnes & Noble hired William Wood as CIO. WSJ

Fortune Reads and Videos

Airlines develop a new seating class...

...and it's worse than coach. Informally dubbed "last class," it includes no pre-assigned seats, and you have to pay for most bags. The low-cost option will be offered by Delta, American, and JetBlue. Fortune

Uber, Lyft drivers earn unionization right in Seattle

It's the first major city in the U.S. to let drivers of hailing services unionize.  Fortune

Shrimp prepped by slaves in Thailand...

…are on the shelves of Walmart, Whole Foods, and Kroger, says a new report. Fortune

The first time Elon Musk met Steve Jobs...

...he thought Jobs was "kind of a jerk." The comments, which Musk tried to backtrack from, adds to the litany of jabs he has sent Apple's way of late.  Fortune

Today's Quote

"We showed the first cut — which was still incomplete, a complete version of the movie but not the finished version — and we showed it to Alan Horn, Bob Iger, and Alan Bergman, the three people at Disney who sat with me in the theater, and we screened the movie. And it was horrifying...I'm nervous beyond words, I'm showing this movie that is so far from finished, there's not an effect in it." - J.J. Abrams talking to Howard Stern about his experience shaping "Star Wars: The Force Awakens" and working with Disney to complete it.  Hollywood Reporter

Share Today's Power Sheet:

Produced by Ryan Derousseau