Power Sheet – October 30, 2015

October 30, 2015, 2:26 PM UTC

A potential Pfizer-Allergan merger (value: at least $120 billion) and a potential Visa-Visa Europe merger (value: $22 billion), both reported yesterday, could extend the already mind-blowing string of 2015 deals – capped for the moment by the $117-billon acquisition of SABMiller by Carlos Brito’s Anheuser-Busch InBev. These deals represent the highest of high finance, and it’s tempting to regard them as primarily exercises in Olympic-caliber number crunching and negotiating. But they’re mainly something else. They are ultimately tests of judgment and leadership, and their lessons hold value for all leaders, even those who will never have to decide whether to spend $100 billion.

Produced by Ryan Derousseau

These deals are far more than mere financial exercises because they force the CEO of the buying company to confront reality fearlessly, to examine his or her own biases, and to question his or her motivations. It all comes down to the price. The main reasons some mergers fail isn’t strategic mismatch or poor integration, though those factors can play big roles; it’s usually because the buyer pays too much. When that happens, the buying CEO has betrayed his or her shareholders by wasting their capital in a deal that cannot create value for them. And overpaying is extremely easy to do.

Investment bankers, who stand to make millions if a deal closes, paint an alluring picture of competitive dominance and personal glory for the potential buyer. The combination will create lucrative synergies and opportunities for cross-selling, the argument usually goes, and enable massive cost savings and economies of scale. And you, Mr. or Ms. CEO, will be remembered as the transformative visionary who made it all happen.

The trouble begins with the fact that the selling CEO can usually calculate the potential synergies and cost savings just as well as the buyer can, so those benefits get bargained away in the price negotiation. Cross-selling is notoriously hard to implement. Synergies – one plus one equals three – are usually a fantasy; it’s tough enough just to make one plus one equal two. To the buying CEO, the negotiation, sometimes involving a rival bidder, becomes a matter of personal victory or defeat.

For an especially lurid example of how badly it can all turn out, look back a decade at Boston Scientific’s fight with Johnson & Johnson to buy Guidant, a medical device maker. Boston Scientific became so obsessed with “winning” that it agreed to an insanely high price ($27 billion, or 52 times earnings) and ironclad terms that left it no outs regardless of what might happen during the months required to close the deal. J&J chief Bill Weldon was happy to drop out of the bidding, confident that Boston Scientific would lose by winning. Which it did. Though the S&P is up 65% since then, Boston Scientific’s share price still hasn’t recovered.

Have any of this year’s mega-buyers fallen into the same trap? Brito had to raise his bid for SABMiller three times. We don’t yet know how much Pfizer’s Ian Read may be willing to pay for Allergan or whether Visa’s Charles Scharf has made a sound deal. We just know they are being tested in a profound way.

Most leaders will never even think about such mammoth transactions. But courage in facing reality, self-awareness in examining our biases, honesty in our motivations – these qualities benefit every leader, every day.

You can share Power Sheet with friends and followers here.

What We're Reading Today

Valeant drops ties with Philidor...

... only four days after CEO J. Michael Pearson defended Valeant's relationship with the pharmacy, which will close. It's unclear if Valeant will receive any of the $100 million it paid Philidor's owners - unbeknownst to shareholders - for the right to take ownership of the pharmacy company sometime in the future. Valeant had also begun incorporating Philidor sales into its own results, though it didn't own the company. It's a dramatic stumble for Valeant, which only five months ago was dubbed the next Berkshire Hathaway by investor Bill Ackman. Fortune

Senate approves budget deal

The new budget, which includes an $80-billion increase in spending over two years and raises the debt ceiling through the rest of President Barack Obama's tenure, heads to the White House. The deal passed 64 to 35, as most Democrats supported the measure while only one third of Republicans did. The biggest critics included presidential candidates Rand Paul and Ted Cruz. The agreement avoids another possible government shutdown, like the one that occurred in 2013. NYT

China warns of war

During military discussions over a U.S. naval ship operating 12 nautical miles from a  Chinese man-made island in the South China Sea, Admiral Wu Shengli said the "provocative acts" could lead to war between the two superpowers. The maneuver by Washington was the most direct challenge to China's territorial claims. In the talks, U.S. chief of naval operations Admiral John Richardson agreed that the two sides should continue to operate under previous protocols.  Reuters

Iran arrests a U.S. executive

Siamak Namazi, an Iranian-American businessman who heads strategic planning at Crescent Petroleum and a vocal advocate of stronger Iran-U.S. ties, was arrested two weeks ago while visiting family in Tehran. The arrest comes in the wake of the Iran nuclear deal as President Obama tries to improve relations with the country. It's a sign that hardliners want to prevent foreign investment. WSJ

Building a Better Leader

Companies that place a high value on design...

...have more productive employees.  Quartz

When dealing with a difficult coworker...

...be careful about what you write in an email. Fortune

Don't forget to turn back your clocks

Daylight savings time ends Sunday morning at 2 am.  USA Today

The 'Trick-or-Treat' Business

The story behind Smarties

This family business, started by Edward Dee, 91, is run by his granddaughters, Liz, Jessica, and Sarah. They were trained young, going to candy conventions as kids. Edward still frequents the factory, offering advice and guidance.  NYT

Where Sexy Donald Trump costumes come from

Chad Horstman, creator of the costume company Yandy.com, known for scanty outfits such as a sexy police officer and, yes, even a sexy Donald Trump, says his business will make $50 million this year. Over 30% of that will come in September and October. Fortune

Americans to spend $6.9B on Halloween 

And that's just on costumes and decorations. For candy makers it's one of the most important days of the year, and prices are on the rise. Here's a look at how some of the largest candy makers produce the treats that your kids (and you) will probably eat this weekend. BBC

Up or Out

Fox TV Group CEO Joe Early has resigned. Hollywood Reporter

David Egner has been named the CEO of the Ralph C. Willson Jr. Foundation. Crain's Detroit Business

Fortune Reads and Videos

Air Force smooths Boeing's feathers

Boeing and Lockheed Martin claim they didn't receive fair treatment during the bidding process to build the next stealth bomber. The huge contract went to Northrup Grumman. Fortune

Self driving cars crash 5 times more often

But we can't blame computers for humans' shortcomings. Fortune

Target to offer free shipping, returns

Target CEO Brian Cornell turns up the heat on Walmart to attract holiday shoppers.  Fortune

Can't argue with LinkedIn's results 

And it doesn't have to rely on advertising. Fortune

Birthday Wishes

Apple CEO Tim Cook turns 55 on Sunday. Biography

The creator of the men's magazine Hustler, Larry Flint turns 73 on Sunday Biography

Share Today's Power Sheet: 

Read More

Great ResignationDiversity and InclusionCompensationCEO DailyCFO DailyModern Board