Former Top Stockbroker on Trial for Losing Clients’ Life Savings

BERLIN, GERMANY - AUGUST 14: A hand puts a dollar bill in a Moneybox on August 14, 2015, in Berlin, Germany. (Photo by Thomas Trutschel/Photothek via Getty Images)
Thomas Trutschel/Photothek—Getty Images

A former Pennsylvania stockbroker who was kicked out of the securities industry and ordered to pay millions of dollars in damages to customers he allegedly fleeced went on trial Monday on an unusual set of criminal fraud charges.

Anthony Diaz was fired by five brokerages and resigned from another amid persistent customer complaints and rules infractions. Yet he kept investing other people’s money until Wall Street’s self-regulator had seen enough and permanently barred him in 2015.

Some investors say they lost their life savings because of Diaz.

“These were exclusively retirees or people close to retirement age when they met Diaz,” said Adam Gana, a veteran securities lawyer who represented some of his former customers. “Widows, elderly, unsophisticated investors who were totally bilked by him.”

The ex-broker has said through his attorney that his actions were “proper and legal.” He pleaded not guilty to an 11-count indictment alleging wire and mail fraud. Each count carries a maximum 20-year prison sentence.

Jury selection began Monday in Scranton.

The trial comes amid a court battle over a new Trump administration rule that requires securities brokers to keep the interests of their customers ahead of their own. Democrats and consumer advocates have said the rule actually weakens investor protections, and seven states and the District of Columbia have sued the Securities and Exchange Commission to block it.

Once regarded as one of the nation’s top brokers, Diaz earned millions of dollars over a 15-year career by pushing high-fee, high-risk “alternative investments” meant for wealthy, sophisticated investors. Prosecutors say he had unsuspecting clients sign blank documents, then falsified their net worth, income, investment experience and risk tolerance to make it appear they met the suitability requirements of the products.

What Diaz sold as “no-lose” investments with guaranteed rates of return were, in fact, highly speculative and came with long holding periods that tied up clients’ money, according to court documents.

The stockbroker also lied to clients about having been fired, the indictment said, claiming he left each firm voluntarily.

The criminal charges against Diaz are “unbelievably rare,” according to Gana. While brokers have been charged with outright theft, Gana said, “I can’t recall a single indictment of a broker for falsifying documents and making unsuitable investments.”

A phone call and email were left with Diaz’s lawyer, Darren Gelber, seeking comment on the government’s case.

Gelber asked a judge to block prosecutors from telling the jury that Diaz had been fired repeatedly and barred from selling securities, saying the information was prejudicial and irrelevant. Judge Malachy Mannion denied the request last week, meaning that jurors will be free to hear about Diaz’s lengthy disciplinary record.

Two years ago, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority ordered Diaz to pay some $4 million in damages to 19 former clients. He has not complied, an agency spokeswoman said last week.

Gana said he looked for assets owned by Diaz that could be used to satisfy the damage award but came up empty, “which is unfortunate because he left a lot of damage in his wake.”

Diaz has skipped out on at least one other judgment.

More must-read stories from Fortune:

—Forget policymakers. Greta Thunberg and her allies are targeting CEOs
—Investors see a 2020 recession coming—but think they’ll make money
—The Carlos Ghosn affair: A look inside the motivations of a fugitive CEO
Laws meant to close down tax havens and shut loopholes could have opposite effect
—What a $1,000 in 10 top stocks a decade ago would be worth today
Subscribe to Fortune’s forthcoming Bull Sheet for no-nonsense finance news and analysis daily.

Subscribe to Well Adjusted, our newsletter full of simple strategies to work smarter and live better, from the Fortune Well team. Sign up today.