Joe Biden’s shift on abortion tests the politics of his faith
It was one of the first stress tests of Joe Biden’s presidential campaign: A sudden reversal of his decades-long support for restricting federal funding of abortions.
The move seemed sure to hurt the former vice president with Catholics, particularly those in the Midwest, whose support will be critical to winning the Democratic primary and the general election. But so far, Biden has faced little criticism over his shift on abortion funding relative to other aspects of his record, and polls show that he remains Catholic Democrats’ overwhelming favorite in the presidential field.
Since the days of John F. Kennedy, Catholic Democrats have wrestled to reconcile their church’s teachings with their party’s politics. That tension has been especially acute when it comes to abortion, with some bishops threatening to deny communion to then-Sen. John Kerry over his support for abortion rights during his 2004 presidential bid. But the church has faced significant upheaval in the 15 years since then, raising questions about whether Biden’s leftward step on abortion is a liability with some voters of faith — or a more minor hurdle at a time when Catholics, like the electorate nationwide, are becoming more politically polarized in the age of President Donald Trump.
Steven Krueger, president of the nonprofit Catholic Democrats, warned that “the far left wing of the party has had influence on a number of issues, particularly on the issue of abortion, that is not going to serve candidates well once they’re in the general election.”
“And the problem is,” Krueger said in an interview, “it’s very difficult to kind of tack back to the middle once you take a stand on something as black and white as whether or not you want to repeal” the restrictions on federal abortion funding that Biden abruptly came out against in June.
Biden called for ending those four-decade-old limits on government health care spending on abortion, often referred to as the Hyde Amendment, under heavy fire from his Democratic rivals. He made the move with a subtle nod to the devout Catholicism that had initially informed his pursuit of a “middle ground” on the matter.
“Just as I’ve never attempted to impose my views on anyone else as to when life begins, I have never attempted to impose my view on who should pay for it,” Biden said as he shifted from supporter to opponent of Hyde, which bars federal funds from use on abortion services except cases of rape, incest, or risk to a woman’s life.
Biden has demonstrated a deep public connection to his faith, dating to the earliest days of his political career. He regularly attends Mass, has met with both Pope Francis and his predecessor Pope Benedict, and credited Catholicism with helping him heal after his son Beau’s death in 2015. Twice last week, during the third Democratic debate and while speaking at a historic black church in Birmingham, Biden cited Danish philosopher and theologian Soren Kierkegaard’s observation that “faith sees best in the dark.”
Sen. Chris Coons, D-Del., a friend and ally of Biden’s, described the candidate’s faith as “deeply personal,” adding: “It’s sustained him through times as hard as anyone’s.”
Biden went deeper on the connection between his Catholicism and his stance on abortion during a recent campaign stop at Limestone College in South Carolina, peppering his theological aside with some Latin references.
“I’m prepared to accept for me, personally, doctrine of my church” about when life begins, Biden said, “but I’m not prepared to impose that on every other person.” He reiterated his support for codifying Roe v. Wade into federal law, if elected.
Abortion is not the only issue on which Biden has split from his church’s official stance. He is a longtime backer of LGBTQ rights, including same-sex marriage. And the same phrase he used to describe his new opposition to Hyde — “circumstances have changed” — could also apply to the calculus for Catholic voters heading into 2020.
According to AP VoteCast, which surveyed voters in the 2018 midterm elections, a majority of Catholics — 57% — said abortion should be legal in most or all cases, while Protestants and other Christians were about evenly divided.
Yet there’s significant regional variation in views on abortion. That variability is notable among Catholic voters in the Midwest, where Biden is campaigning as a potential Democratic nominee who’s uniquely positioned to win back the less liberal working-class voters Trump appealed to in 2016.
In the East, West and South, Catholic voters were nearly as likely as voters in those regions overall to believe abortion should usually or always be legal. But Midwestern Catholics, whom Democrats need to perform well with to stay competitive in a general election, were significantly less likely than regional voters overall to hold those more permissive views on abortion, 47% versus 58%.
The truest test of Biden’s ability to stay dominant with Catholic voters, often viewed as one of the few remaining swing demographics in a polarized electorate, isn’t likely to come unless he makes it to a general election against Trump. In the event of a Biden-Trump matchup, when Catholic voters in the upper Midwest would be key, conservatives are likely to try to use the Democrat’s shift on abortion against him.
The Republican National Committee lambasted Biden as overly beholden to his party’s liberal base in the immediate aftermath of his shift on abortion funding, which he announced amid an outcry from the left over new state laws limiting women’s ability to end pregnancies. Ralph Reed, the well-known conservative evangelical strategist working to help reelect Trump, lashed out at Biden for showing that “for him, politics trumps principle” and later predicted to reporters that Biden would pay a price with Catholic bishops for his move.
To be sure, leaders of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops remain stalwart supporters of the restriction on federal funding of abortions, which is a fixture in the law with bipartisan backing.
“Whether you like it or not, the consensus in America is abortion is legal and available, and no one has to pay for anyone else’s abortion or participate in anyone else’s abortion,” John Carr, a former longtime adviser to the bishops, said in a recent interview.
“When Republicans go after the first, I think they scare people,” added Carr, founder of Georgetown University’s Initiative on Catholic Social Thought and Public Life. “When Democrats go after the second, which is ‘you’re going to have to pay for or maybe participate in an abortion,’ they scare off other people.”
But as the bishops’ broader political influence wanes somewhat, and Trump’s immigration policy stokes religious progressives’ interest in applying a “pro-life” ethos to other issues, abortion may not hold as much sway over Catholic voters in 2020 as it did in previous elections.
Sister Simone Campbell, executive director of the NETWORK Lobby for Catholic Social Justice, lamented that her faith’s ethic of protecting life is often “reduced” to the question of whether to “criminalize abortion.”
“Our faith teaches us the dignity of all life. We have to look at that broader spectrum,” said Campbell.
Sister Carol Keehan, who recently retired as head of the Catholic Health Association, described herself as “extraordinarily pro-life” and supportive of the Hyde Amendment, but she also contended that Biden is “pro-life” on many fronts reflected in his policy decisions, including his support for an assault weapons ban and for federal support of children’s health insurance.
Both Keehan’s and Campbell’s groups notably broke with the bishops during Biden’s time as vice president in a dispute over the Affordable Care Act’s treatment of abortion funding.
As religious activists on the left urge voters of faith to look beyond single-issue voting on abortion to a more expansive definition of “pro-life,” Trump himself may hold the key to Biden escaping significant peril with Catholic Democrats. A Quinnipiac University poll released in May found 55% of Catholic voters saying they would definitely not support Trump’s reelection, versus 41% of Protestants and 70% of those with no religious affiliation.
“To the degree Vice President Biden may have given pause to persuadable Catholic voters” with his shift on abortion, Krueger said, “there remains a countervailing imperative for Catholics to replace our nation’s 45th president.”
More must-read stories from Fortune:
—Super Tuesday results so far: Biden wins Virginia’s Democratic presidential primary
—Twitter’s testing new ways to fight misinformation. Is open-source the answer?
—Meet Trump’s Giuliani-approved power broker—and Melania’s new senior adviser
—Angela Merkel is on her way out. Meet her potential replacements
—How the 2020 election could influence your personal finances
Get up to speed on your morning commute with Fortune’s CEO Daily newsletter.