At Crunch Time for U.S. Drillers, Warm Weather Threatens Meltdown

Fracking In California Under Spotlight As Some Local Municipalities Issue Bans
LOST HILLS, CA - MARCH 24: Pump jacks are seen at dawn in an oil field over the Monterey Shale formation where gas and oil extraction using hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, is on the verge of a boom on March 24, 2014 near Lost Hills, California. Critics of fracking in California cite concerns over water usage and possible chemical pollution of ground water sources as California farmers are forced to leave unprecedented expanses of fields fallow in one of the worst droughts in California history. Concerns also include the possibility of earthquakes triggered by the fracking process which injects water, sand and various chemicals under high pressure into the ground to break the rock to release oil and gas for extraction though a well. The 800-mile-long San Andreas Fault runs north and south on the western side of the Monterey Formation in the Central Valley and is thought to be the most dangerous fault in the nation. Proponents of the fracking boom saying that the expansion of petroleum extraction is good for the economy and security by developing more domestic energy sources and increasing gas and oil exports. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images)
Photo by David McNew via Getty Images

By Joshua Schneyer and Scott DiSavino

Dec 20 (Reuters) – Strapped for cash, Chesapeake Energy Corp (CHK) cancelled its traditionally grand display of holiday lights this year, but like most oil and gas drillers it is still dreaming of a white Christmas.

A mild North American winter could punish large drillers, especially gas giants like Chesapeake, by curbing seasonal demand for heating of homes and businesses and hurting prices.

Energy companies, laden with debt and reeling from a 17-month collapse in oil prices, may now face their most critical few months of the decade-long U.S. fracking boom. So far, the weather is not going their way.

Typically by the second half of December between a third and half of the United States has snow cover. This year, it is limited mostly to sparsely populated areas of the upper Midwest and Rockies region, said AccuWeather Senior Meteorologist Dale Mohler.

For drillers, that means sharply lower returns at a crucial time.

At gas fields across the country, “instead of a mentality of growth it’s now a mentality of survival,” said Charles Nevle, vice president at PointLogic Energy in Houston. “And right now, it’s all about the weather.”

Two Texas-based drillers, Magnum Hunter Resources Corp (MHR) and Cubic Energy Inc (CBNR), filed for bankruptcy this week. Chesapeake, the No. 2 U.S. gas producer, is working with Evercore Advisors to restructure debt or sell assets.

On Friday, U.S. natural gas futures dropped to a 16-year low of $1.68 per million British thermal units on the New York Mercantile Exchange. Supplies for delivery through the first quarter are trading below $2 for the first time since the 1990s.

Two more months of mild weather could send natgas futures as low as $1.25, said energy analyst Kyle Cooper of IAF Advisors and Criterion Research. That would be well below what it costs drillers to pump new supplies from the ground.


Cities reliant on natgas for heating are on track for one of the balmiest Decembers ever. In the first half of the month, heating degree days — a measure of cold weather-driven demand for heating — were 36 percent below average in Chicago, and 42 percent off in St. Louis, according to AccuWeather.

Last week, U.S. natural gas stocks were 16.4 percent higher than year-ago levels. Production is only slightly off from September’s record highs.

After two frigid winters, this one may continue to be mild due to El Nino, said MDA Weather Services meteorologist Don Keeney. The weather phenomenon can result in temperate westerly winds across North America.

Utilities store gas in caverns so they have enough fuel for heating during the November-March period, but relatively flush stocks in spring could force drillers to cut output next year due to lack of storage space.

U.S. drillers have avoided that fate in the past. During a mild 2012 winter, they switched their focus to more lucrative oil wells instead of gas.

But with U.S. oil futures near six-year lows, there is little appetite for new oil wells.


Prices in natural gas import-reliant regions like Asia are far higher, but the United States lacks infrastructure to ship there immediately. Pipeline exports have grown to Mexico, which buys up to 5 percent of U.S. natgas, but analysts say demand may not warrant further expansion.

Years of oil and gas drilling zeal over the past six years have now left global markets oversupplied. OPEC countries, meanwhile, have opted not to curb their own oil production, and await shale drillers to cut first.

U.S. gas drillers have been firing workers, delaying projects and deploying far fewer rigs.

“We’re looking for some pretty dramatic supply curtailments,” said Teri Viswanath, director of commodity strategy for natural gas at BNP Paribas.

A wild card is whether the weather could still turn sharply colder. December’s warmth has been so extreme that an atmospheric “rebalancing” resulting in more typical storm patterns may occur in January, said AccuWeather’s Mohler.

U.S. gas demand has also shown some bright spots. As ultra-cheap natural gas displaces coal, power generators have consumed record volumes of it this year, accounting for 35 percent of U.S. production.

But a mild winter could also take a far greater toll on producers who have not protected themselves from lower prices.

According to consultancy Energy Aspects, the 20 biggest independent gas producers have hedged just 32 percent of their expected 2016 output, or far less than in previous years.

“Producers have been saying ‘how much lower can prices go?'” said PointLogic’s Nevle. “It looks like they’re going to find out.”

(Reporting by Joshua Schneyer and Scott DiSavino; Editing by Lisa Shumaker)

Subscribe to Well Adjusted, our newsletter full of simple strategies to work smarter and live better, from the Fortune Well team. Sign up today.