Power Sheet – November 12, 2015

November 12, 2015, 3:44 PM UTC

Is there some particular reason that lots of companies should be in crisis right now? I can’t think of any. The global and U.S. economies are not great but not terrible. Stock markets are holding up well, expressing at least moderate confidence in the future. And yet, while I don’t think anyone keeps track of companies in crisis, the roster at the moment seems large. So let’s take advantage of this opportunity to grade five CEOs being tested in situations that will define their leadership. Four of the five don’t qualify for a grade of A because they were in charge when the crisis-causing behavior happened; the fifth is eligible for an A but doesn’t get one

Produced by Ryan Derousseau

Michael Pearson, CEO of Valeant: B+ Valeant’s problems became a no-fooling crisis when short-seller Andrew Left accused the company of using its ties to Philidor Rx Services to pump air into revenues. Pearson severed ties to Philidor and on Tuesday admitted mistakes and outlined a general plan for Valeant’s strategy and finances. Investors acknowledged that he allayed some concerns but not all.

Matthias Mueller, CEO of Volkswagen: C- Mueller wasn’t the boss when VW installed emissions-test-cheating software in millions of cars, but he’s behaving almost as if he had been. He has been saying many of the right words – VW has lost customers’ trust and must regain it through behavior, the culture must change, the company will investigate and be transparent with its findings – and the company has indeed released damaging information on its own. But this is the basic playbook for anyone in his situation. He has shown no passion for his most important job, culture change.

Elizabeth Holmes, CEO of Theranos: D The fundamental technology underlying her company’s $9-billion valuation is in question, and she is offering little but assurances that everything will be okay. Give her credit for showing up at last week’s Fortune Global Forum and at an earlier WSJ conference to address the issue, but she admits no errors beyond not doing a good job of communicating. “I’m definitely not a PR person,” she told Fortune editor Alan Murray last week, but others say that, having built a hugely valued medical device company without getting even one peer-reviewed evaluation of her technology, she’s actually a highly skilled PR person.

Nigel Eccles, CEO of FanDuel, and Jason Robins, CEO of DraftKings: ?? Who knows how well they’re managing this crisis? New York’s attorney general has alleged that their business is gambling and therefore illegal in New York; Nevada has already ruled likewise. If their business model is widely outlawed, their only praiseworthy response will be coming up with a new one. And we simply don’t know if they can.

There probably is a particular reason all these CEOs in widely diverse industries are learning crisis leadership at the same time. It’s part of the new normal in a digital economy; even at big, old VW, the crisis involves software. Ones and zeroes can change fast; competitors arise out of nowhere; the world is becoming radically transparent. Leaders had better get used to it: Even if the economy is booming and stock prices are rocketing, crises will only multiply.

You can share Power Sheet with friends and followers here.

What We're Reading Today

Fortune's Businessperson of the Year: Mark Parker

The unsung hero of Nike's success announced in October that he would grow the company's annual revenue by $20 billion, to $50 billion, by 2020. Despite Nike's size, it continues to grow 8.5% a year. Parker is an introvert and doesn't grab many headlines, yet he and Nike founder Phil Knight have more in common than you might think. You can find the full list of Fortune's best leaders of the year here. Fortune

Charles Koch non-committal on support

Billionaire Republican donor Charles Koch said he doesn't plan to support any candidates during the primaries. His network of donors is expected to raise between $750 and $889 million over two years. He hasn't spoken to any of the candidates since August, though his brother David has. USA Today

Macy's battles struggling sales

CEO Terry Lundgren announced that Macy's sales had declined 5.2% in the third quarter vs. 2014, a steeper drop than most had feared. In response, Macy's will launch Macy's Backstage, a discount operation that will compete with TJ Maxx and Marshalls. While Lundgren continues to defend the department store's place in the e-commerce world, investors wonder what other tools he can deploy to boost sales. The board has supported Lundgren, but activist investors have begun to circle. WSJ

Ackman attacks Buffett's Coca-Cola shares

At an event to celebrate Warren Buffett's 50 years at Berkshire Hathaway, activist investor Bill Ackman questioned the Oracle's investment in Coke. "Coca-Cola's business model is to displace the water that children and adults consume with sugar water," said Ackman. The surprising shot from Ackman comes as he defends his investment in Valeant, a pharmaceutical company whose stock price has dropped 70% since August.

Building a Better Leader

Birchbox's largest competitor: Non-consumption

Co-founder Katia Beauchamp is focusing the company on battling this issue rather than fighting with competitors. Fast Company

Intuit CEO Brad Smith's $40 million mistake

It came before he joined Intuit in the late 1990s; he enthusiastically backed a product that achieved total sales of $1,500. But Smith learned from the blunder. Fortune

If you want to become a leader...

...you have to start acting like one by taking initiative. Inc.

Worth Considering

Volkswagen to offer impunity to employees

As VW and CEO Matthias Mueller investigate the full extent of the diesel emissions cheating scandal, the carmaker will offer employees full immunity for information. The announcement is expected to give employees until the end of November to come forward with details. It comes as an anonymous-tip system has failed to produce much information, while the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency grows impatient with the company's slow progress in the investigation.   WSJ

5 candidates pass FIFA's ethics review 

After an internal ethics review, FIFA has approved five of the seven candidates who seek to succeed the embattled Sepp Blatter as president of the soccer federation. It rejected the candidacy of Michael Platini of France, who faces a corruption investigation in Switzerland, and Musa Bility of Liberia. Prince Ali bin al-Hussein of Jordan, Jérôme Champagne of France, Gianni Infantino of Switzerland, Tokyo Sexwale of South Africa, and Sheikh Salman bin Ebrahim al-Khalifa of Bahrain were approved to move forward. Blatter has been hospitalized after suffering "a small emotional breakdown," but he will continue to fight his 90-day suspension from FIFA.  NYT

EU and Israel battle over wine labeling

The European Union will move forward with labels on wines and other products that identify them as made in Israeli settlements, not Israel. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the move "hypocritical and a double standard," since the EU is not requiring similar labeling of products from territories in conflict elsewhere.  Fortune

Up or Out

Former VW CEO Martin Winterkorn has resigned as the company's Audi Group chairman. Business Insider

Robert van der Zalm has resigned as CFO of commodities trader Noble Group, citing health reasons. He will become vice chairman of finance at the company. MarketWatch

Fortune Reads and Videos

Apple's working on a new money feature

You may soon be able to send cash to friends via your iPhone. Fortune

Walmart will stock up for the holidays

This year it will not use gimmicks such as advertising sales but limiting the quantity of the product in stores. Fortune

Small daily fantasy competitors close shop in New York

DraftOps has already complied with New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman's ruling that daily fantasy sports games are illegal gambling.  Fortune

AirBnB promises to help with long-term housing shortages

It will also pay more taxes and work more closely with cities. Fortune

On this day...

...in 2013, U.S. Airways and American Airlines's parent company AMR agreed with regulators to settle an antitrust suit by giving low-cost airlines more access to airports. The agreement allowed the companies to merge, creating the world's largest airline.  Reuters

Share Today's Power Sheet: 

Read More

Great ResignationDiversity and InclusionCompensationCEO DailyCFO DailyModern Board