CEO DailyCFO DailyBroadsheetData SheetTerm Sheet

Market gains fizzle ahead of today’s jobless data

April 23, 2020, 9:41 AM UTC

This is the web version of the Bull Sheet, Fortune’s no-BS daily newsletter on the markets. Sign up to receive it in your inbox here.

Good morning, Bull Sheeters. Oil prices have recovered. Stocks though are mixed.

Let’s take a look at what’s moving markets.

Markets update


  • Asia is mostly in the green, led higher by Japan’s Nikkei. A rally on Hong Kong’s Hang Seng lost steam in afternoon trade.
  • We’re getting fresh reads on the economic impact of coronavirus: Japan revealed manufacturing activity fell by the most since 2009. And Singapore is bracing for a big hit to GDP this year.
  • Oil-reliant Saudi Arabia, meanwhile, plans to slash spending and borrow its way out of the crisis, suggesting it could raise as much as 220 billion riyals ($58 billion) in debt to plug the supertanker sized hole in its national budget.


  • European bourses are mixed. Milan, Paris and Madrid are clinging to gains while Frankfurt and London falter. The benchmark STOXX Europe 600 Index was up nearly a half-percent at the open, before slumping.
  • There’s another make-or-break EU summit scheduled today. Member states are still far apart on how to finance the recovery. The Italians want coronabonds, per favore. And the Germans? Nein!
  • While they dither, the ECB unveiled a plan aimed at protecting the bloc’s hardest hit economies. It reads as if they’ve lifted the text straight from the Fed’s rescue plan. It involves accepting junk debt as collateral for loans.
  • We knew Q1 car sales would be bad, but this bad? German auto giant Daimler is looking at a near 70% plunge in quarterly sales, forcing it to scrap its full-year forecast. That’s a lot of Mercedes sitting idle in showrooms.


  • The Dow, S&P 500 and Nasdaq futures point to a flat open after yesterday’s impressive gains.
  • The markets took off in afternoon trade yesterday as Congress voted to send another giant stimulus package to the president’s desk.
  • It’s Thursday, so all eyes will be on the jobless claims numbers, set to be revealed before the market open. Economists forecast another 4 million will have applied for unemployment benefits in the past week, taking the tally to over 25 million in the past month.


  • Gold is up, slightly.
  • As is the dollar.
  • Crude continues to bubble up, extending yesterday’s rally. WTI futures surpassed $15/barrel—cheap, but oil traders will take it. Brent, the global benchmark, is steady in the low twenties.

Trillion dollar question

Each Thursday throughout this crisis, economists examine the latest jobless claims numbers and then take a hard look at their GDP projections. Pandemic economics you might call it.

GDP growth and unemployment rates are closely tied. But how closely tied is open to some debate. Many economists work off an old model that adapts Okun’s law, named after the American economist Arthur Okun. I wrote about this in the latest issue of Fortune. I’m going to share a small part of that analysis here this morning:

Okun’s law goes something like this: for every 1% rise in the unemployment rate, you get a 2% fall in GDP. That might be too extreme a calculus these days as the CARES Act, for one, is meant to blunt the economic destruction of mass unemployment posed by the coronavirus in the short term.

And so Goldman Sachs has developed a modified Okun—the “half-Okun,” if you will—that suggests a 1:1 correlation between rising unemployment and falling GDP. 

But even the half-Okun paints a frightening picture. With consensus GDP expectations suggesting a drop of more than 30%, that would portend Depression-era jobless numbers.

Drilling down on GDP now…Goldman forecast late last month a 34% drop in Q2 GDP (it wasn’t the only one putting a negative-30 handle on Q2), led by stunning drops in consumer spending and manufacturing, particularly in April. You can see where much of the pain will play out in today’s chart.

Since this initial calculation, Congress has passed more stimulus measures—four in total. So, the “positive effects from fiscal response” on the right side of the chart could be more pronounced, blunting the negative effects on spending on the left.

But that will be of small comfort to the millions who’ve filed for unemployment benefits in recent weeks.


Is there an award for “lockdown heroes?” If so, I’d happily nominate 13-year-old Vittoria Oliveri and Carola Pessina (11) from Finale Ligure, in the north of Italy. Their tennis club posted a video of them playing rooftop tennis.

They’re absolutely crushing it!

The ATP Tour was so impressed they posted it to their Twitter feed. You can check out the action here.

I’ve been sneaking a peek to watch and rewatch their tremendous volley. Don’t mess with these two!


Have a nice day, everyone. Stay safe and sane. I’ll see you here tomorrow.

Correction and update, April 23, 2020: This post has been updated to correct the spelling of Okun’s Law.

Bernhard Warner

Looking for more detail on coronavirus? Fortune has a new pop-up newsletter. The aptly named Outbreak will keep you up to date on the latest news surrounding the coronavirus outbreak and its impact on business and commerce globally. Sign up here.

And, you can write to or reply to this email with suggestions and feedback.

Today's reads

The Yang gang returns. Former Democratic presidential hopeful Andrew Yang is among those backing a project to distribute $1,000 each to 100,000 low-income families hardest hit by the coronavirus pandemic, Fortune’s David Z. Morris reports. Project 100, also supported by tech startups and charities, is a small-scale version of Yang’s flagship proposal during this year’s Democratic presidential contest for a “Freedom Dividend”, a universal basic income that would pay every American adult $1,000 a month in response to job losses caused by automation.

Who's pocketing PPP loans? Dozens of publicly traded companies have received funds from the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP), angering small businesses that were meant to be the beneficiaries of the coronavirus aid scheme, Fortune’s Chris Morris reports. A new study by Morgan Stanley (as reported by CNBC) finds at least 75 public companies pocketed $243 million from the program. Ay...

Crash-proof stocks. It’s madness for investors to embrace companies that are getting a short-term boost from the coronavirus pandemic but whose long-term future is bleak, says portfolio manager Adam Seessel. Investors should instead search for companies with a durable competitive advantage. There are dozens of Alphabet- and Amazon-like companies with long-term tailwinds that will emerge better and stronger on the pandemic’s other side, Seessel writes in Fortune.

Market candy


That’s how much shares in Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG) rose Wednesday after the burrito chain said first-quarter revenue was boosted by strong digital sales as coronavirus lockdown measures took hold. That's a lot of burritos.