Gartner says more servers sold this quarter, but for less money.
The number of servers sold worldwide grew just a scooch in the first quarter, while total server revenue dipped, according to new numbers from market research firm Gartner.
For the first quarter of 2016, Gartner it said revenue from server sales fell 2.3% to $13 billion from almost $13.4 billion for the comparable period last year. But the number of total boxes shipped rose 1.7% to just over 2.7 million from 2.66 million.
(For comparison purposes, Gartner’s fourth quarter numbers showed that worldwide server revenue grew 8.2% while unit shipments rose 9.2%)
Get Data Sheet, Fortune’s technology newsletter.
The latest figures are another indication of a key trend in modern IT, and one that’s got traditional server makers—the Dells, the Lenovos lnvgy , the HPEs hpe of the world—on the defense: More big web-scale companies are designing their own servers and having them made by contract manufacturers instead of buying name-brand servers.
Massive cloud providers also known as “web scale” or “hyperscale” companies include Amazon amzn Web Services, Microsoft msft , Google goog , and Facebook fb . These companies deploy thousands upon thousands of servers in their data centers, divvying the work among them. When one fails, the applications are designed to reconfigure around the bad box, which gets swapped out.
This is what is called “scale-out” computing as opposed to the “scale-up” model exemplified by Oracle orcl Exadata servers or mainframes where a single, albeit very powerful computer takes on big workloads. While those big boxes suit some enterprise situations, it’s clear that more companies are offloading at least part of their work to cloud providers, which means they buy fewer servers less often than they had in the past. That’s the pinch the branded server manufacturers have found themselves in.
The big growth server vendors per this report are Huawei and Inspur, which showed 24% and 19% unit growth respectively year over year, albeit that growth came off a much smaller base compared with the other server companies. Neither of those companies cracked the top 5 list in terms of revenue. Or, as Gartner analyst Jeffrey Hewitt put it in a statement:
In terms of revenue, HPE held onto the top slot with 25.2% market share and server revenue of nearly $3.3 billion, up 3.3% from a year ago. But it shipped slightly fewer servers year over year. Dell remained No. 2 with 17.3% share, but revenue dipped 1.4% to $2.26 billion from $2.29 billion a year ago. IBM was third at 9.7% market share but saw its revenue decline a whopping 32.7% year over year to $1.27 billion from $1.89 billion a year ago.
Gartner’s findings diverged slightly from figures from rival research firm IDC, which found that both server revenue and unit numbers slipped in the first quarter. According to IDC, server revenue fell 3.6% year over year to $12.4 billion total and server shipments were off 3% to 2.2 million.
For more on HPE, watch:
In a statement, IDC attributed the declines to both an end to an enterprise server refresh cycle and to a “pause in hyperscale cloud expansion.”