Eighty percent of employees today say that AI makes them more productive, yet only 37% of organisations see any EBIT impact. For nearly two in three organisations, none of the value that is felt is yet banked.
The problem isn’t that organisations lack the data to make better decisions. It’s that knowing what needs to happen and being willing to act on it are two very different things. An Irish rugby win, a long Italian summer and an aircraft waiting at the gate all illustrate this same tension: the data knew what was optimal long before the organisation was willing to move.
Rules with owners
Many of the constraints holding that value back are not rules at all. They are past decisions that have hardened into rules, and people have the power to change them.
Leading a global industry team, and later our strategic business transformation team at Google, I often got personally involved with customers who had committed substantial spend but were not yet seeing the value.
One was a large aviation partner accustomed to leading, where each team had always defended its own part. With a tenured EVP as sponsor, millions in multi-year capital and the best teams on both sides, they built a solver to weigh crew, aircraft rotation, passengers and ground control at once. Only legislation, capacity and safety went in as constraints; everything else went in as input. Every time someone said “I just know,” we went back to what had driven that decision, and coded it in only if it held true for the future.
The solver’s value was proven, yet it took 18 months to go from accepting half its recommendations to almost all. The controllers, carrying responsibility for passengers’ lives, set the pace; every recommendation they accepted questioned the judgement they had built a career on. The airline became one of the most profitable in the world, but expanding it across the network stalled on decision hierarchies and the fear of an AI model overruling decades of service. None of it came from doubting the value. It came from a constraint that lives in people, not in the system.
You can automate the analysis and still preserve the corporate politics. Last week an advisory client told me, with real pride, about their newly implemented dynamic pricing model, and in the next breath listed all the constraints they had put into it. They had bought a model to find the future and fenced it in with the past. None of this is new; AI’s power just moves it from project conversations to business-defining ones.
Paid for the past
The model can recommend the move; only the bonus plan can approve it. More than a decade ago at Diageo, we combined sell-out, sentiment, media spend and weather data by brand and country. When Ireland’s rugby team won, money worked harder on TV and Guinness than where the plan was first built. When the sun stayed in Italy, Tanqueray’s season ran longer. It was just math. But every euro moved changed which country manager would hit the target they had staffed against, who would gain their bonus, and who would have to tell their family that this year’s summer vacation was at stake. The tool remained a lagging indicator of what could have been.
That is what sits between the 80% and the 37%. People use AI to do tasks faster, and are often asked to do much more with the time it frees. When AI is the reason given for cutting headcount, showing how much it saves you can feel like drafting your own redundancy. We are shaving tasks off old roles, and no one is paid to imagine the new ones.
The incumbent in all of us
Every employee is now an incumbent. It is the classic incumbent’s dilemma, lived in every individual: protect the past or own what comes next. At Maersk ten years ago, I lived it at corporate scale. Margins were thin and the value lay in customers’ wider supply chains, but a company that owned ships had to prove it would choose the carrier best for the customer, not for its own fleet. We carried that burden of proof. In 2016, the industry was not profitable; integrated logistics paid off through the pandemic, and last year Maersk earned$3.5 billion in operating profit. Our job as leaders is to help people see a future that the right capabilities can contribute towards.
Often that future is already there, in the work people are proudest of. After a session I led recently, an executive assistant pulled me aside. She had just heard me speak about what AI means for the business and for the individual. She used AI a lot, more than her boss knew, and she was worried she would be replaced. I asked her where she had last felt incredibly valuable and proud of her contribution. She told me how she had brought a leadership team of strong personalities, each set on proving their own contribution, behind one common goal. She saw them as individuals and caught their fears before they were voiced. She knew her role was not a task; it was to create an environment where they could let their guard down long enough to align. If an AI model were ever trained to do that, she would be the one to train it, and it would let her scale as never before. What stood between her and that future was not technology. It was knowing her own value.
Multiply her by a workforce, and you have the gap between the 80% and the 37%. The economy organises around its next constraint. Until now, it was something we could raise, build or buy. This time, it is us.
Moving the constraint
In my advisory work, four moves always help address the human barrier.
Start from the ideal ambition, not from today. An outcome is too small; it invites people to optimise the present. An ambition lets them imagine where they stand in it.
Audit the constraints, including the ones in our heads. It takes curiosity to ask what drove each rule and whether it still fits the future, and honesty to name the narratives we still cling to.
Steer the system, not just the budget. Tie part of every target to the shared result. Pay tells people how they are coping this year; ownership tells them whether they take part in the next ten. People read what really counts from who gets promoted.
Live the change before you ask for it. If every hour saved becomes a headcount cut, people will hide it. When 69% of executives use AI less than an hour a week, we are executing a transformation we ask others to inhabit, while quietly negotiating how much of ourselves we will change. People feel it long before they can voice it.
What are you doing differently this week? I have seen, again and again, how quickly an organisation moves once its leader does. Momentum does not start with the plan. It starts with the first honest move, and that move is ours to make.
The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.
