Great ResignationDiversity and InclusionCompensationCEO DailyCFO DailyModern Board

Why Caterpillar’s Doug Oberhelman Is Leaving

October 18, 2016, 3:14 PM UTC

I was sorry to see Caterpillar’s announcement yesterday that CEO Doug Oberhelman would retire a year early, on January 1, after four years of falling sales. The board was right to act. But Oberhelman’s story is a reminder to all leaders that the phrase “high risk, high reward” has never been entirely correct. More accurately, if less euphoniously, it states, “High risks bring the chance of big rewards but also of big losses.”

Oberhelman took bold risks that looked brilliant, and the world loved them. They just didn’t work out.

The irony is that Cat is performing poorly now in part because it performed so well in the financial crisis and recession. Far-sighted management by former CEO Jim Owens, carried out in part by Oberhelman, brought the company through the recession in far stronger shape than after previous downturns.

In addition, Oberhelman had been named to the top job six months before he took over, and he used the time to assemble a strategy team and study the environment. “We charted out that we want to be the leader in every market in which we compete and every industry in which we compete by 2015. To do that, what do we have to do in investments, plants, people, distribution? We had all this going in four or five months time. It was really a great exercise,” he told me then.

Clear imperatives emerged: Get bigger in mining, eco-friendly engines, and railroad equipment; bulk up heavily in regions where growth is greatest, especially in infrastructure—in other words, in China, India, and Brazil.

And the strategy team made a further key decision: Invest early in this cycle, using Cat’s financial strength while others might still be recovering.

So that’s what Oberhelman did almost immediately, putting billions in new capital into the business. Such a move can be dangerous, but Oberhelman was a disciplined manager who tracked operating profit after deducting a full capital charge, a measure known as economic profit. Wall Street was enthusiastic about all of it. When Oberhelman announced his biggest acquisition, the $8.6-billion purchase of a mining equipment manufacturer called Bucyrus International, investors actually bid Cat’s stock up, which as a reaction to an acquirer’s move is almost unheard of.

What neither Oberhelman nor the board nor investors foresaw was that China’s growth would slow, Brazil would go into recession, commodity prices would plunge, and sales of Cat machines would consequently dry up.

In businesses with capital-light business models, management can turn on a dime as conditions change. Manufacturing some of the world’s largest land-based moving objects is not one of those businesses. Everybody liked Oberhelman’s audacious strategy when he executed it, but when it didn’t pan out, he had to take the fall. That’s the nature of leadership. So let’s congratulate him, console him – and then consider the risks we’re taking in our own leadership.

You can share Power Sheet with friends and followers here.

What We're Reading Today

Visa CEO to step down
The surprise decision by Charlie Scharf comes as the company has been performing well. Scharf felt he could no longer do the job at Visa headquarters in San Francisco while also fulfilling family obligations in New York. Visa director and former American Express president  Alfred Kelly Jr. will take over as CEO. Fortune

State Department fought the FBI on Clinton emails 
Documents newly released in the Hillary Clinton email investigation show that State Department officials urged the FBI to declassify an email found on her personal server. Undersecretary of State Patrick Kennedy tried to convince the FBI to declassify the message. The FBI says no "quid pro quo" was offered -- the FBI declassifying the message in return for the State Department approving the posting of more FBI agents to Iraq -- though the documents suggest otherwise.  CNN

Samsung to compensate Galaxy Note 7 parts makers
The South Korean government is worried about the economic effects of Samsung's decision to stop manufacturing the Galaxy Note 7. In response, Oh-Hyun Kwon's company will compensate suppliers and potentially use them to source parts for new models. Reuters

Julian Assange's email has been cut off
WikiLeaks says Ecuador has severed Assange's internet access because he published transcripts of Hillary Clinton's Wall Street speeches. Assange has lived in Ecuador's London embassy for over four years, fearing that if he leaves he could be detained for a rape allegation he faces in Sweden and then extradited to the U.S.  The Guardian

Building a Better Leader

Americans work about 25% more hours than Europeans
The Swiss come closest to matching Americans' hours while Italians lag by 29%. Bloomberg

What keeps CFOs up at night
Maximizing shareholder value tops the list, ays Cisco CFO Kelly Kramer. Also:  keeping Wall Street analysts' alternative universe in perspective.  Fortune

When working from home...
...continue to wear work clothes. You'll feel more authoritative, trustworthy, and competent. Fast Company

Shopping Choices

Macy's to open early on Thanksgiving
As a number of mall operators and retailers announce they'll close on Thanksgiving, Terry Lundgren's company will open an hour earlier than last year, citing customer interest. The decision shows the importance of the holiday season  to Macy's prospects as the company struggles to grow. USA Today

Walmart moves its CEO to the forefront
In a rare move for the retailer, Walmart is featuring CEO Doug McMillon as a spokesperson in commercials, positioning the company as committed to its employees. This is the first time Walmart has used a CEO in an ad. The strategy can be risky, as CEOs may lack charisma, and linking the company to the face of the executive can make leadership changes awkward. WSJ

Under Armour athletes must have this
Speaking at the Fortune Most Powerful Women Summit, Under Armour SVP of global retail Susie McCabe says athletes the company sponsors must have character as well as astounding athletic talent. Since the athletes become linked to the business, "we are then responsible for how that reflects on our brand," she says.  Fortune

Up or Out

McDonald's chief field officer Karen King will retire at the end of the year. Fortune

Apple has hired Ruslan Salakhutdinov as director of AI research. Fortune

Fortune Reads and Videos

IBM will not run Watson...
...on any other company's cloud, such as Amazon Web Services. IBM made that very clear during an earnings call yesterday. Fortune

Facebook is testing a Messenger feature...
...that enables the tool to suggest what you should talk to your friends about. Fortune

U.K. government lawyer says Parliament will "very likely"...
...need to ratify any Brexit deal. The announcement sent the British pound soaring, since most members of Parliament oppose leaving the E.U. Fortune

In a mock election...
...American K-12 students elected Hillary Clinton. The mock election has been wrong only twice since 1940. Fortune

Quote of the Day

"I’d go into businesses that I had no right to go into, but I always felt like I could bring something interesting." -- BBG Ventures president Susan Lyne, discussing her career path from print journalism to digital media at the Fortune Most Powerful Women Summit.  Fortune

Share Today's Power Sheet:

Produced by Ryan Derousseau