• Home
  • Latest
  • Fortune 500
  • Finance
  • Tech
  • Leadership
  • Lifestyle
  • Rankings
  • Multimedia

Trendingnow

1

MacKenzie Scott alone accounted for one-third of America's $19.2 billion in megagifts last year

2

Elon Musk on MacKenzie Scott giving away $26 billion of her fortune: 'Sadly,' it makes the world a worse place

3

Philanthropy leader at Warren Buffett and Bill Gates’ Giving Pledge says children of billionaires are pushing them to give their wealth away faster

1

MacKenzie Scott alone accounted for one-third of America's $19.2 billion in megagifts last year

2

Elon Musk on MacKenzie Scott giving away $26 billion of her fortune: 'Sadly,' it makes the world a worse place

3

Philanthropy leader at Warren Buffett and Bill Gates’ Giving Pledge says children of billionaires are pushing them to give their wealth away faster

Why lawyers are still fighting over 9/11

By
Matt Vella
Matt Vella
Down Arrow Button Icon
By
Matt Vella
Matt Vella
Down Arrow Button Icon
September 18, 2012, 4:04 PM ET
Add Fortune on Google for similar content.

By David A. Kaplan, contributor



FORTUNE — Call it garden-variety legal thinking — or jurisprudential chutzpah. It all depends on how you look at it. When two commercial jetliners, commandeered by suicidal Al Qaeda terrorists, smashed into the towers of the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, they surely were the primary causes of thousands of lost lives and billions in lost property. But can legal blame also be assessed to some degree on the airlines, an airplane manufacturer, and private checkpoint-security firms that let the terrorists get on the planes and hijack them?

That’s the question a federal court jury may get to decide in the coming months or years. It’s been more than a decade since 9/11 — and billions of dollars in damages have been paid by both the U.S. government and private insurers to passengers on the planes, companies and individuals in the towers, firefighters and police officers, and a range of other victims. But the lawyers are still at it in two big conjoined cases.

In 2004, the owners of the twin towers — World Trade Center Properties (WTCP), which consists of Silverstein Properties and several other major investors — sued various airlines and security contractors for alleged negligence that contributed to the attacks. The claim: On the ground and in the air, United and American Airlines, along with the firms they hired to handle security, could have done much more to prevent the tragedy. WTCP also blames Boeing (BA), which made the planes that hit the towers, for “defective design” of the cockpit doors and failing to install a security system that would alert the FAA if a plane were taken over. World Trade Center Properties v. United Airlines, Case No. 08-CV-03719 and World Trade Center Properties v. American Airlines, Case No. 08-CV-03722.

At stake is up to $6 billion. Though the towers’ owners sought even more, the judge limited potential damages to the fair market value of the 99-year lease that the owners held in lower Manhattan. That lease was for $2.8 billion; depending on how a court calculates interest since 2001 (as much as 9% a year), the total could more than total that. The damages would be paid by insurers.

MORE: Ding Dong vs the Ho Ho: Hostess labor fight continues

Late last month, U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein ordered the case to proceed with more discovery and move toward a trial. He denied a motion by the airlines and other defendants to throw out the case on their theory that WTCP had been paid enough. WTCP has already recovered $4 billion from property insurance claims (it initially demanded roughly twice that, based chiefly on the argument that the attack on the World Trade Center constituted not one but two separate insurable events). In the current suits, WTCP want additional damages based on the negligence theory. The judge said it was premature for him to rule on the defendants’ motion.

In a subsequent frustrated letter to the court, lawyers for the towers’ owners urged the judge to get on with a trial. “In the wake of 9/11, Congress elected to protect [the defendants] from financial ruin by limiting their liability to the amount of their insurance,” wrote Richard Williamson, WTCP’s lead attorney. “But, surely, when bestowing such an enormous benefit…Congress never envisioned a decade-long flight by their insurers to walk away with most of that insurance money untouched and earning returns while victims—and New Yorkers—wait to be made whole both economically and through full restoration of the World Trade Center site.”

Then, noting the arrival of the “11th anniversary of that devastating day,” Williamson added, “The time has come for the public finally to hear [our] overwhelming evidence of how [defendants] ignored government warnings about terrorist threats, failed in their duty to keep the terrorist hijackers from the boarding the aircrafts with deadly…weapons, and manufactured and operated planes without safeguards to prevent the terrorists from gaining access to the cockpits.”

United Airlines told Fortune it would not comment on current litigation. Other defendants did not respond to requests for comment. Lawyers for the owners of the towers also declined comment.

Because most major World Trade Center litigations have ended by now — including wrongful-death lawsuits brought by families — the WTCP cases may seem like a relative footnote. But in its potential to unveil in open court a full accounting — under cross-examination — of airline and airport security practices before 9/11, the cases are worth watching.

About the Author
By Matt Vella
See full bioRight Arrow Button Icon
Add Fortune on Google for similar content.

Latest in

Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025

Most Popular

Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Finance
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam
By Fortune Editors
October 20, 2025
Fortune Secondary Logo
Rankings
  • 100 Best Companies
  • Fortune 500
  • Global 500
  • Fortune 500 Europe
  • Most Powerful Women
  • World's Most Admired Companies
  • See All Rankings
  • Lists Calendar
Sections
  • Finance
  • Fortune Crypto
  • Features
  • Leadership
  • Health
  • Commentary
  • Success
  • Retail
  • Mpw
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
  • CEO Initiative
  • Asia
  • Politics
  • Conferences
  • Europe
  • Newsletters
  • Personal Finance
  • Environment
  • Magazine
  • Education
Customer Support
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Customer Service Portal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms Of Use
  • Single Issues For Purchase
  • International Print
Commercial Services
  • Advertising
  • Fortune Brand Studio
  • Fortune Analytics
  • Fortune Conferences
  • Business Development
  • Group Subscriptions
About Us
  • About Us
  • Press Center
  • Work At Fortune
  • Terms And Conditions
  • Site Map
  • About Us
  • Press Center
  • Work At Fortune
  • Terms And Conditions
  • Site Map
  • Facebook icon
  • Twitter icon
  • LinkedIn icon
  • Instagram icon
  • Pinterest icon

Latest in

Nike’s earning numbers exceeded Wall Street’s expectations. But CEO Elliott Hill’s next test is the World Cup
RetailNike
Nike’s earning numbers exceeded Wall Street’s expectations. But CEO Elliott Hill’s next test is the World Cup
By Mia OsmonbekovJune 30, 2026
9 hours ago
Dell’s AI boom is real, but so is the profit margin hit nobody is pricing in
AIDell Technologies
Dell’s AI boom is real, but so is the profit margin hit nobody is pricing in
By Mia OsmonbekovJune 30, 2026
10 hours ago
Young couple looking sad in front of a home with a for sale sign
Real EstateHousing
Gen Z and millennials aren’t convinced the American Dream exists anymore: Only 40% of them can afford to buy a home
By Tristan BoveJune 30, 2026
10 hours ago
Russian President Vladimir Putin
EconomyRussia
It started with one viral influencer complaining about Russia’s economy. Now a record 60% of Russians are pessimistic about their country’s outlook
By Tristan BoveJune 30, 2026
12 hours ago
Image of colored bar charts with one being pushed up.
NewslettersEye on AI
AI is minting billion-dollar companies faster than before
By Beatrice NolanJune 30, 2026
12 hours ago
Stripe CEO Patrick Collison gestures with his hands as he speaks into a microphone before a congressional committee hearing.
Cryptostablecoins
Stripe, Visa and over 140 other businesses to launch stablecoin to rival Tether and Circle
By Camila Grigera NaónJune 30, 2026
12 hours ago

Most Popular

MacKenzie Scott alone accounted for one-third of America's $19.2 billion in megagifts last year
Success
MacKenzie Scott alone accounted for one-third of America's $19.2 billion in megagifts last year
By Sydney LakeJune 25, 2026
6 days ago
Elon Musk on MacKenzie Scott giving away $26 billion of her fortune: 'Sadly,' it makes the world a worse place
Success
Elon Musk on MacKenzie Scott giving away $26 billion of her fortune: 'Sadly,' it makes the world a worse place
By Sydney LakeJune 29, 2026
2 days ago
Philanthropy leader at Warren Buffett and Bill Gates’ Giving Pledge says children of billionaires are pushing them to give their wealth away faster
Success
Philanthropy leader at Warren Buffett and Bill Gates’ Giving Pledge says children of billionaires are pushing them to give their wealth away faster
By Preston ForeJune 27, 2026
4 days ago
'Humanity has chosen to become idiots': This Brown professor switched to take-home exams after a mass shooting and discovered mass cheating
AI
'Humanity has chosen to become idiots': This Brown professor switched to take-home exams after a mass shooting and discovered mass cheating
By Catherina GioinoJune 29, 2026
1 day ago
The retired college professor fighting a $313 trespassing ticket in Wisconsin thinks he's part of a national struggle
Environment
The retired college professor fighting a $313 trespassing ticket in Wisconsin thinks he's part of a national struggle
By Catherina GioinoJune 28, 2026
3 days ago
The U.S. Army is opening military bases to private billions — here's why that changes everything for the next 250 years
Commentary
The U.S. Army is opening military bases to private billions — here's why that changes everything for the next 250 years
By Marc AndersenJune 30, 2026
18 hours ago

© 2026 Fortune Media IP Limited. All Rights Reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy | CA Notice at Collection and Privacy Notice | Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information
FORTUNE is a trademark of Fortune Media IP Limited, registered in the U.S. and other countries. FORTUNE may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.