Salesforce Target Tableau Explored Sale Earlier This Year by Reuters @FortuneMagazine October 19, 2016, 5:06 PM EST E-mail Tweet Facebook Linkedin Share icons Tableau Software, one of the companies in a leaked list of potential acquisition targets of Salesforce, worked with an investment bank to explore a sale earlier this year, according to people familiar with the matter. Shares of Tableau rose as much as 7.3% on Wednesday after the Wall Street Journal reported the list, found in emails of former Secretary of State Colin Powell that were published in September by DCLeaks, a website that releases information often obtained through cyber security breaches. Powell sits on Salesforce’s board of directors. Tableau, which has a market capitalization of $3.8 billion, worked with investment bank Qatalyst Partners to discuss a potential deal with interested companies and private equity firms, the people said on Wednesday. However, the negotiations ended by the summer without a deal, the people added. Get Data Sheet, Fortune’s technology newsletter. The sources asked not to be identified because the deliberations were confidential. Tableau data declined to comment, while Qatalyst and Salesforce crm did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Tableau was described as “in play” in the Salesforce list, produced last May. The list also includes many enterprise software companies that have already sold themselves in the wave of consolidation that has swept the technology industry. Large software companies such as Salesforce and Microsoft msft are flush with cash, while technology-focused private equity firms such as Vista Equity Partners and Thoma Bravo have raised large funds. Microsoft Just Acquired LinkedIn LinkedIn lnkd , another Salesforce acquisition target, agreed in June to be bought by Microsoft for $26.2 billion. Another of Tableau’s competitors in business intelligence software, Qlik Technologies qlik , agreed to sell itself to private equity firm Thoma Bravo for about $3 billion earlier this year. Seattle-based Tableau, which makes software that turns complicated data into graphics that can be easily analyzed, had one of the most highly expected IPOs of 2013. Marketo mkto , which began trading on the same day and was also on Salesforce’s target list, was sold to Vista Equity for $1.79 billion last summer. Tableau Just Enlisted This Former Amazon Exec as Its New CEO Still, investors have fretted over one of Tableau’s key growth measures, its license revenue, which has stalled in recent months. In February, its stock price fell nearly 50% upon the release of its fourth-quarter earnings. Its shares, which traded as high as $105 in November 2015, were up 4.3% at $49.13 in late trading on Wednesday. Tableau, co-founded by Stanford University professor Pat Hanrahan, developed animation software that powered movie studio Pixar. Large enterprise customers, such as Barclays, IKEA and Deloitte, use its programs to cut back on the use of spreadsheets.