Commentary

Is Facebook Allowing Advertisers to Discriminate by Race?

Oct 28, 2016

Facebook is about to have yet another, very uncomfortable conversation about race.

A new story from the investigative journalist organization, ProPublica, has revealed that the company not only allows advertisers to target users by specific attributes, they also let them eliminate users on the basis of race, a practice which is at best, alarming, and at worst, illegal. “Imagine if, during the Jim Crow era, a newspaper offered advertisers the option of placing ads only in copies that went to white readers,” their report begins.

Imagine indeed. From the story:

“The ubiquitous social network not only allows advertisers to target users by their interests or background, it also gives advertisers the ability to exclude specific groups it calls “Ethnic Affinities.” Ads that exclude people based on race, gender and other sensitive factors are prohibited by federal law in housing and employment.”

ProPublica further drives their point home by successfully purchasing an ad via the Facebook ad portal targeted to people looking for housing but eliminating black, Asian and Hispanic users. Not only is this potentially a legal issue, it feels like a digital continuation of the redlining and similar practices that have historically prevented people of color from homeownership, financing, and employment.

Facebook’s business model depends on advertising. To that end, they give advertisers the ability to target users to an exceptional degree of specificity. Not only do they collect an extraordinary amount of data about people based on their activity on the platform, they also enhance their databases with information they purchase from data brokers about offline behaviors as well. Ultimately, people can be categorized in nearly 50,000 different ways. The company told ProPublica that they're vigilant about preventing discrimination or abuse on their ad platform and that exclusion is an important way that advertisers can test the effectiveness of ad copy, for example. But this episode will be hard to explain away.

If nothing else, this report should raise - yet again - important questions about how the algorithms that increasingly define our lives are shaping the world in unseen ways. With all their data and predictive analytics at their fingertips, how could Facebook not have seen this coming?

I've reached out to Facebook for comment and will update this story with their response.

On Point

Minneapolis has a race problem and it's affecting their economy

Compared to other American cities; Minneapolis has relatively low unemployment, scant poverty, affordable housing and a preponderance of Fortune 500 company headquarters. But a recent analysis of census and other data reveal a tale of two cities: A yawning wealth, employment and homeownership gap between white residents and people of color. And people are upset about it.

The Atlantic

A new study shows racial bias in teacher referrals to gifted and special needs programs

New research from New York University shows that racial bias plays a significant role in whether teachers refer students to either gifted or remedial programs. Teachers were more likely to see academic deficits in white students as disabilities requiring assistance, and less likely to refer students of color to gifted programs, even when they had similar attributes as their white peers.

Chalkbeat

Retraining police will not prevent bias

Three criminal law professors think that anti-bias training will have little impact on the racial disparities that continue to exist in policing and criminal justice. Instead, they recommend “blinding” the prosecutors, who have the most unchecked power in the system. “Our work on bias in the criminal justice system suggests that preventing racial information from reaching key decision-makers could be the best way to make justice truly blind.”

PBS

A Federal Reserve Bank CEO gets real about race

In a candid set of remarks, John C. Williams, the President and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, admitted that he’d been the recipient of “a healthy, and perhaps needed, kick in the pants to move faster and be more accountable regarding our progress on diversity and inclusion.” He lays out some familiar challenges, in particular, the difficulty of getting diverse employees into management and beyond. “Despite our efforts, our diversity pipeline drops from a torrent to a trickle once employees reach the cusp of leadership positions.”

Federal Reserve Bank of SF

Can virtual reality help eliminate bias?

There is real reason to believe that the deeply immersive experience of virtual reality, if designed correctly, can function as an “empathy machine” enabling people to viscerally experience the lives of others. Even the NFL is currently exploring how to use virtual reality technology to help staff and athletes confront racism and sexism.

Huffington Post

Viola Davis has sold her first show to ABC Studios

Davis' production company, which she runs with her husband, Julius Tennon, has sold its first show to ABC, a musical comedy set in 1968 called The Zipcoders. It's about a divorced mom whose teen sons decide to start a Beatles-style rock band. It was created by Marshall Todd, best known for writing Barbershop. “This project gives me the opportunity to tell a story that, while specific to the African-American experience, doesn’t travel in the usual tropes,” he said.

Hollywood Reporter

The Woke Leader

Nigeria has a design problem

Olatokunbo Fagbamigbe and JR Kanu are the co-founders of The Design Institute, in Lagos Nigeria, and both have sterling credentials in the corporate world – Stanford, Google, IBM and more. In this fascinating post, they explain how “proprietary design,” the protectionist and patriarchal rules of formal Nigerian society, has held the country back from innovation and social change. Their solution is an inclusive, open source and collaborative approach to product design and leadership, which is challenging social norms.

Design Blog

Wearing hijab at work is a constant battle against stereotypes

Muslim women who choose to wear hijab are largely invisible in the workplace, underrepresented in leadership and in creative roles. Fast Company has an outstanding profile of three fascinating professional hijabi who have said their visible embrace of their faith has brought unique benefits along with the issues. “I had to live in and constantly fight against an identity that I was completely unaffiliated with,” says one. A must read.

Fast Company

Six books from diverse authors to read now

Writer Grace Talusan offers this review of new books from mostly Asian or Asian American women with a gentle reminder: If we want diverse points of view in literature, we need to buy the books, particularly when the writers are either new to publishing or trying a new genre. One author you may have heard of: Christine Hyung-Oak Lee, who became a viral sensation with her Buzzfeed essay, “I Had A Stroke At 33.” She's written a memoir of what, sadly, she doesn’t remember.

Vela Mag

All products and services featured are based solely on editorial selection. FORTUNE may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.

Quotes delayed at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by Interactive Data. ETF and Mutual Fund data provided by Morningstar, Inc. Dow Jones Terms & Conditions: http://www.djindexes.com/mdsidx/html/tandc/indexestandcs.html. S&P Index data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions. Powered and implemented by Interactive Data Managed Solutions