Are trick-or-treaters more likely to be subjected to Candy Corn, or will they be blessed with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups this Halloween? It all depends on which state you live in.

Candystore.com has collected and analyzed its sales data to discover which candy is most popular in each state, and D.C., on Halloween. The website looked at sales from 2007 through 2015 during the three months before the holiday, and verified their information against that of larger candy companies.

Here are the best-sellers in each state: